Quantcast

Spinning

krazyfranco's picture
Posts
158
Member
380 days
started by krazyfranco on July 29, 2007

Would spinning this winter do anything for me on the bike? I don't think I'm ready to invest in a trainer.
Thanks

Triguy98's picture
Posts
2268
Member
1132 days
Triguy98 posted 41 weeks ago.

Spinning will help some, but I wouldnt rely on it for big improvements. The best way to get better on the bike is to ride more. If it's too cold and/ or dark for you to get one long ride in during the winter, look into trainers. They're not really that expensive if you don't go with a fluid trainer. While fuilds are nice, the magnetic trainers work pretty darn well, and the newer ones arent that loud at all. I picked up my Minoura 850 w/ remote for around $100- new.

Life is short. Play hard and get dirty doing it.

krazyfranco's picture
Posts
158
Member
380 days
krazyfranco posted 41 weeks ago.

Thanks Triguy-
Any tips on trainers? i really know next to nothing about them

Triguy98's picture
Posts
2268
Member
1132 days
Triguy98 posted 41 weeks ago.

I've only used a couple. The Cyclops Fluid2 is considered one of the best there is, but it's $300. I can feel a difference between it and my lower end Magnetic trainer, but not $200 worth of difference. ;)
Just hunt around online untill you find a trainer in your price range- whatever that may be. As I said, I found my Minoura 850D prety cheap w/ free shipping.

Life is short. Play hard and get dirty doing it.

qb ant's picture
Posts
563
Member
1249 days
qb ant posted 41 weeks ago.

I got a Minoura (older model can't remember which) at a place called Play It Again Sports for $80. While it might not be the best out there, well worth the 80 bucks. Look around or on ebay, I'm sure you can find a deal. I'll take a spin class about once a week and it's great for cardio, but nothing beats riding your bike.

"90% of the game is half mental" Yogi Berra

Amy Lee's picture
Posts
283
Member
1189 days
Amy Lee posted 41 weeks ago.

I pretty much used spin classes as my "bike training" my very first season because I found it difficult to get actual road time on the bike with my young kids. I have to say I did pretty well considering.. but cycling is the one and only leg that comes kind of naturally to me.

Now well into my third season, I do train more outside but rely on my cycleops fluid trainer heavily. I am a certified spin teacher up here in Maine, so I design my profiles and test drive them on my trainer a few times before delivering them to a class.

If your going to use spin class for training puposes I suggest finding an instructor who has outdoor riding/racing experience and who creates cycling profiles with a "purpose". It's not about riding to the beat of the music and bike "choreography." The classes should include a variety of different profiles which include strength, interval training, endurance, recovery and race day. If you find yourself in classes which continuously appear to be "all terrain"...meaning including a little of everything at an intense effort, then your probably doing yourself more harm than good. These types of classes over time just wear your muscles and joints down and you end up getting very little benefit. Bottom line ...you have to get a good instructor who knows and cares about what they are doing.

I agree with the others that you should invest in a trainer. I had my first magnetic trainer for 20 years. It just recently rusted out and I bought the cycleops to replace it. It's worth the investment and you'll never have an excuse not to ride in the winter.

Good luck!

Amy

krazyfranco's picture
Posts
158
Member
380 days
krazyfranco posted 41 weeks ago.

Thanks for the feedback! I will look into getting a decent used trainer, unless winter is mild :) We can only hope!

Slimpee's picture
Posts
81
Member
442 days
Slimpee posted 41 weeks ago.

I did a training class this winter-it kicked my butt!

I'm not used to keeping a high HR or pedaling constantly when I bike so it was a wakeup call! Do one and see how you like it.

Theia's picture
Posts
23
Member
290 days
Theia posted 41 weeks ago.

Amy Lee;74789 wrote:
If you find yourself in classes which continuously appear to be "all terrain"...meaning including a little of everything at an intense effort, then your probably doing yourself more harm than good. These types of classes over time just wear your muscles and joints down and you end up getting very little benefit.

I too am a Spinning instructor (as well as other exercise formats). I sure wish some of my fellow instructors would read your point, above, instead of just trying to kill everyone with their dazzlingly hard classes week after week. It makes it so much more difficult for those of us who take time to plan out our classes, have a purpose, and try to teach rather than just sit up front and scream when the members are convinced that harder always equals better. *sigh*

bokchoy's picture
Posts
39
Member
1316 days
bokchoy posted 41 weeks ago.

I just wanted to chime in on Spinning too. I found it very helpful in the winter just for overall cardio conditioning. I have great instructors who are all cyclists, so they definitely made the class feel more like a ride than an aerobics class. But, it was still night and day to actually riding.

I think it's a great thing to do, just another thing to keep your lungs working hard for 60-90 minutes.

beads1985's picture
Posts
3685
Member
1527 days
beads1985 posted 41 weeks ago.

I am doing a spinning class several times a week. I get different traing from different instructors. If I am not comfortable doing what they are instructing I just do my thing. I sit in the back of the class so I am not disrupting them.

I usually follow that with a swim at the Y. It is a great combo workout.

I also spend time on my trainer at night.

All this in addition to outdoor riding. I just need to find more time to get my outdoor rides in. :rolleyes: