Quantcast

Camelbacks?

azstinger11's picture
Posts
376
Member
542 days
started by azstinger11 on December 9, 2006

Hey,

So I have had a camelback for sometime now and love it dearly but what i'm wondering about it is should i keep using it while i'm training. I have never seen any pics of people actually using them in Tris so i'm guessing they aren't allowed? Any thoughts/wisdom on this subject would be helpful:)

-----------------------------------------------
Base 1 (Week 2, 16.5hrs)
Check out my blog!

JamieM's picture
Posts
825
Member
1172 days
JamieM posted 1 year ago.

I don't know of any reason that they would not be allowed, andI have seen one or two in races. I have one, but only use it formountain biking. I think most roadie/tri types just prefer regular bottles.

triNick's picture
Posts
225
Member
1066 days
triNick posted 1 year ago.

They are allowed, no problem at all. In fact, I think I remember seeing a woman pro at this years race in Kona with a camelback. I'd have to look to go see who it was. If you watch the IM broadcast today on NBC I'd bet you'd see her with it on. (I found it, the pro wearing the camelback at Kona this year was Lisbeth Kristensen. Triathlete Magazine (Jan. 07 issue) has a picture of her at Kona with her camelback)

I have a friend that's not too coordinated, she actually wiped out pretty good during a race trying to put her water bottle back in the cage. So now she uses a camelback, I told her to get an aero-bar water bottle so she wouldn't have that problem.

For short distance races you wouldn't need it. For a half or IM, maybe. The thing is, most races, not all have a good setup when it comes to aid stations, they are there to help you replenish along the way during the race. So, you don't need to worry about not having something to drink during a race.

If I'm doing an 75-100 mile bike and the road I'm going to be on doesn't have many places for me to stop and buy something to replenish with, I'll take a camelback on the ride. For a race I'll have my aero-bar water bottle and one other water bottle on my bike, that's it, for 1/2 IM and IM distance races.

Oh yeah, don't worry about what other people might think or say, you do what you are comfortable with. If that's what's going to get you through the race, then use it.

TRImapper.com - visual triathlon finder
TRIJUICE.com - triathlon resource blog

tcrunner07's picture
Posts
350
Member
1221 days
tcrunner07 posted 1 year ago.

i think im going to use my camelback for my first HIM on the bike

If you get a flat, and don't have a tube, Suck it up and run it in!!!

Fivetenfrank's picture
Posts
20
Member
825 days
Fivetenfrank posted 1 year ago.

Another vote for NOT using a Camelback for anything less then a HIM. The reasons are simple - you're not going to consume 70 oz of water on the bike in a sprint or oly; it just another item to put on in T1.

I use mine religiously for training anything over 50 miles especially in the hot weather. Otherwise, I use my aqua rack or bottles on the bike.

Anton's picture
Posts
2374
Member
1169 days
Anton posted 1 year ago.

I use mine for training rides in areas with little services.
For races...no way.
A 70 oz camel back weighs almost 4.4 lbs.
Two twenty ounce water bottles weigh about 2.5.
I vote lighter and use the bottle exchange.

"What would life be if we had no courage to attempt anything?"
- Vincent Van Gogh

My Blog: http://anton.trifuel.net

azstinger11's picture
Posts
376
Member
542 days
azstinger11 posted 1 year ago.

hmm ok thanks for all the input guys. For now I'm defiantly going to stick to using it. Still unsure about the race as I'm not the most graceful/balanced person on the bike I'd prefer to just grab the hose from the camelback instead of fumbling around with my water bottles.

-----------------------------------------------
Base 1 (Week 2, 16.5hrs)
Check out my blog!

glbrum's picture
Posts
835
Member
1180 days
glbrum posted 1 year ago.

tcrunner07;58084 wrote:
i think im going to use my camelback for my first HIM on the bike

If the race you are going to do has aid station on the bike, you don't need to. Bring 1, maybe 2 bottles on the bike with you and grab 1 or 2 during bike when you run out.

Airborne's picture
Posts
149
Member
1225 days
Airborne posted 1 year ago.

Another factor not yet mentioned is HEAT. I find that wearing a camelbak on the bike makes my back all hot and sweaty, even on cooler days. I just wore one for a marathon, and liked it, but on the bike, it's just too hot for me.

Also, maybe I have my camelbak set up poorly, but because of my very aggressive position on the bike, I can't get any water out of the thing while in aero. I have to go up on the hoods so that gravity can do its work and get the water to come out of the straw. Just a thought.

kylie's picture
Posts
3476
Member
1445 days
kylie posted 1 year ago.

when I do wear mine, sometimes it helps me stay cool, opposite Airborne! I don't remember all cases, but I know there have been a few adventure races where the cool water against my back felt pretty good. Although it was 105 or so out that day in the desert, the water stayed cool (until it was gone... oops).

RV's picture
Posts
3184
Member
1213 days
RV posted 1 year ago.

Maybe a guy thing - but I find the camelback very hot on the bike when temps go up. The contents definitely did not stay cool for very long at all. The sports drink from the camel back was actually hot to drink. Maybe because of being in an areo position on the bike and baking under direct sun. Just not something that I'll do again. Better on the run, (Only for training) but mine must not fit great as I will chafe with it. It also made the steep hills seem worse. Thinking of carrying this weight up the hills.

RV

It takes a long time to get good. - Scott Molina
Slow is smooth; smooth is fast. - Rich Strauss

kylie's picture
Posts
3476
Member
1445 days
kylie posted 1 year ago.

maybe it has to do with the pack and it's construction... I guess I got a good one! (not made by camelback by the way... but I like it more than all of theirs that I have ever seen. It's a Gregory Reactor).