Quantcast

racing with music

thebeatcatcher's picture
Posts
115
Member
751 days
started by thebeatcatcher on December 6, 2006

does anyone ever race (HIM, IM) with mp3 players?

i like listening to music when i workout and was just wondering if it would make a difference to train with music and then not race with it. sometimes certain music can get me in a groove and keep me motivated. i know it wouldn't make sense in a shorter race, but what about the longer distances?

i'm not trying to win the race or anything, just wondered if any 'completers' out there like me did this.

Tikal Dog's picture
Posts
1040
Member
1387 days
Tikal Dog posted 1 year ago.

I haven´t read usat rules but ITU states clearly that it is NOT ALLOWED!!!!

Hyperactive Trifueler!!!! (I refuse to let the status go :p)

JamieM's picture
Posts
834
Member
1362 days
JamieM posted 1 year ago.

Goes for the USAT races I've done as well. No headphones.

kylie's picture
Posts
4483
Member
1635 days
kylie posted 1 year ago.

Personally it annoys me when people have music in races because they can't hear what is going on around them. It can be busy on the bike and if someone is passing you it's good to know so you don't swerve as you go for a bottle, etc.

And it is against the rules in pretty much every tri I've ever done or followed. It is a safety issue -- if you can't hear, and they are calling for people to pull over/stop running to get an ambulence through, that could be bad news for someone already having a tough time.

As for training with tunes making it hard to race without them, I think there is some validity in that. Just like we practice transitions and bricks and other things to be ready for (both physically and mentally) on race day, you should practice how you will race. I'm not saying every time (I enjoy running with music sometimes as well) but enough that it isn't another mental hurdle for you on race day. You'll have enough to overcome in those distances without throwing in suddenly having to spend the whole day with just your thoughts! :)

deepbluex's picture
Posts
691
Member
1143 days
deepbluex posted 1 year ago.

The only time I listen to music is when I'm swimming laps in a pool. Biking and running are sufficiently "interesting" that my mind focuses on the task at hand. Swimming laps on the other hand... that gets pretty monotonous so I appreciate having a swimp3 to keep me company.

On race day, everything is interesting. I don't feel the need to listen to anything to take me away from the moment other than my labored breathing and the surrounding noise. I just enjoy the view and take in the experience.

bluebirdbiker's picture
Posts
2866
Member
1304 days
bluebirdbiker posted 1 year ago.

I agree w deepbluex that .."race day everything is interesting I don't feel the need to listen to anything to take me away from the moment". But I gotta say for training that bike and run I am a slave to the mp3 player. 100% of the time.

BBB
There are no excuses - so don't look for them. As a product of your own choices, you directly determine your life outcomes.
Don't think, just do.
My Blog

dr_rios_ec's picture
Posts
814
Member
1159 days
dr_rios_ec posted 1 year ago.

I think racing with music...will make you miss 90% of the experience...the ambiance of the race, the crowd cheering...your stride, your footsteps or cadence...your breathing...what other racers have to say...you name it....
For trainning...I am a total slave of my player....200%

-Santiago
"Man!! Defeat is worse than dying, cause´you have to live with it" -My Dad
"It ain´t about how hard you can hit...it is how hard you can get hit and keep moving forward"-Rocky Balboa

JamieM's picture
Posts
834
Member
1362 days
JamieM posted 1 year ago.

I agree with the others that racing with music, in addition to posing a safety hazard, you're missing some of the experience. And you'll never find me in the gym without my Ipod, cause I can't deal with their choice of music.

deepbluex's picture
Posts
691
Member
1143 days
deepbluex posted 1 year ago.

people won't cheer for you when they see you wearing headphones and you won't hear people cheer for you when you are listening to music.

cheers sound nice. you hardly ever get to hear that. mp3s, you can hear anytime.

beads1985's picture
Posts
4914
Member
1717 days
beads1985 posted 1 year ago.

I train with my iPod, especially on the treadmill, bike trainer or on trail runs if I am by myself.

Most races prohibit them, and some even enforce the rule.
I prefer to race without.
I like the race experience, the sights and sounds.
It gives me a boost of adrenaline.:D

Nothing to it, but to do it

lowlight's picture
Posts
16
Member
1866 days
lowlight posted 1 year ago.

last year at the Vashon Island Xterra the head ref told everyone he was looking for earphones, and if you use them, you will be DQ'ed on the spot.

i tend to do most of my running on trails so i prefer to hear the forest. during the summer i commute on my bike and for that i simply MUST have my iPod. i couldn't handle the commute without my tunes. :)

thebeatcatcher's picture
Posts
115
Member
751 days
thebeatcatcher posted 1 year ago.

i get the whole against the rules thing, didn't really think about that, and the ambiance and experience.

but for those of you who always train with music, so it is not an issue to race w/o it? doesn't change anything really?

rcortesi's picture
Posts
147
Member
1315 days
rcortesi posted 1 year ago.

Used to train with music much more often then I do now.

If I do listen to music, its in the winter when I would like to be distracted from the cold and the fact that I'm out of shape.

Once I no longer feel like I'm completely dragging (at the end of the winter/early spring) I will train without music most of the time. I find it slows me down.

If I'm listening to music I'm not concentrating on my form, pacing, or plan. And I'm definately not pushing myself as hard as I should be. I causes me to loose focus.

This winter I'm going to try to do much less training with music in the name of building mental toughness.

Its a crutch.

Roger

--
"Outside a dog, a book is man's best friend.
Inside a dog it is too dark to read."
Groucho Marx

for athletes http://rogercortesi.com/athleticlog/
for nerds http://rogercortesi.com/eqn/

glbrum's picture
Posts
835
Member
1369 days
glbrum posted 1 year ago.

I used to listen to music when I ran and sometimes on the bike, but I stopped. It's distracting! I'd rathert focus on the task at hand or think about life or just be quiet. Don't get me wrong, I love music, but I think that life can be so cluttered with music and tv that ridng/running without bring a little bit of sanity to my life. Riding/Running is often times a great time to get away and not think about what's going on, but to be out on the bike or running.

An iPod/MP3 player is just one more thing I don't want to wrry about during a race. As I think about some past races, I think I would be annoyed to have music blasting into my ears.

Just my $1.02

cayman's picture
Posts
804
Member
827 days
cayman posted 1 year ago.

I'm still one of the hold outs, I don't even own an Mp3. Like most here, I think it would take away from the experience of racing and even training.

But then, I don't do treadmills, where the teduium and boredom would even get me to buy an Ipod.:D

john
Pain is inevitable. Suffering is optional.

Anton's picture
Posts
2936
Member
1358 days
Anton posted 1 year ago.

What else can I say? Raceing with music is a dumb idea...
Listening to tunes while riding or running outside is a dumb idea too. You need to be in tune with your environment to be safe...period.

"What would life be if we had no courage to attempt anything?" - Vincent Van Gogh
My Blog: http://agingsuperhero.blogspot.com

RV's picture
Posts
3354
Member
1403 days
RV posted 1 year ago.

I don't race (obviously) or even train with an MP3. Safety on the road is too important. For me it is just too much of a distraction even when on the treadmill.

RV

It takes a long time to get good. - Scott Molina
Slow is smooth; smooth is fast. - Rich Strauss

Red5's picture
Posts
736
Member
887 days
Red5 posted 1 year ago.

I still can't believe some of you ride with an iPod. I think that is so profoundly unsafe. I'm not interested in hijacking this thread with a pro-con debate on riding with headphones, I just worry about my tri-peeps here at TriFuel and don't want to see anyone get hurt. We have had a rash of car-bike incidents here in Phoenix (none of which were related to iPods) and I just want evryone to be extra careful.
In regards to this post, you will be plenty preoccupied during a race, you won't even notice the music is gone.

_______
Bryan

Of course it's 'effing hard, it's IRONMAN!

trithis04's picture
Posts
414
Member
1366 days
trithis04 posted 1 year ago.

Red5;57892 wrote:
I still can't believe some of you ride with an iPod. I think that is so profoundly unsafe. I'm not interested in hijacking this thread with a pro-con debate on riding with headphones, I just worry about my tri-peeps here at TriFuel and don't want to see anyone get hurt. We have had a rash of car-bike incidents here in Phoenix (none of which were related to iPods) and I just want evryone to be extra careful.
In regards to this post, you will be plenty preoccupied during a race, you won't even notice the music is gone.

Red, search the old threads for riding + music. What you'll find should be entertaining. There's an old thread on this topic. If I remember correctly, one of the posts says "You don't need to hear when riding a bike."

[FONT=Impact]-Jason
"Fatigue will make cowards of us all!"

Red5's picture
Posts
736
Member
887 days
Red5 posted 1 year ago.

I think I was here for one of those debates and also got sucked into one over at SlowTwitch....but I care more about you guys :).

_______
Bryan

Of course it's 'effing hard, it's IRONMAN!

NateDawgK2's picture
Posts
118
Member
1417 days
NateDawgK2 posted 1 year ago.

personally, I prefer to listen to music - at all times
I understand the safety concerns on the bike

but I think its stupid to not allow headphones during the run, whats the sense in that
show me a running race that doesnt allow headphones; every foot race I have ever been in I wore headphones, and I survived without getting run over, trampled or spontenously combusting

I dont use them riding though, although I would like too, its too dangerous to not hear cars, and if you are in a group not hear the other riders; this past summer I was riding with my g/f and her brother, and he was using an ipod with only one headphone in so he could still hear, and he didnt hear me tell him when to make a turn, so he rode off in the wrong direction for about a mile before I chased him down

has anyone seen the new pearl izumi vertex cycing shorts, with the built in player
like or not, people are going to listen while they ride, and the companies take notice

but I do think headphones should be allowed on the run
just my 2 cents

~No Excuses~
[url=http://www.imagetrash.net]

Riverbrady's picture
Posts
560
Member
1590 days
Riverbrady posted 1 year ago.

I wouldn't ever race with music: the safety issue, the rules issue (which is due to the safety issue), and the experience.

I do train with music off and on. I find it a useful tool to get me through those long runs when energy is low, or through time spinning on the bike when I've no desire to watch yet again something else, or have friends to spin with. That said, while running with phones it's purely trail running and the like...and even so I generally only run with one earphone in so if there is something unexpected, or if I need to hop on a crossover to get to the next trail, I can tune out the tunes and tune into the road.

"Care more than others think is wise, risk more than others think is safe, dream more than others think is practical, expect more than others think is possible."

Red5's picture
Posts
736
Member
887 days
Red5 posted 1 year ago.

Headphones are prohibited in nearly all races I have ever participated in. It's more than just a car safety issue, the race organizers want to be able to communicate instructions to particpants at any time without the hinderence of headphones. Now, often the rule is not enforced, but I don't think it's a "stupid" rule at all. I find it amazing that people would actually wear headphones WHILE racing. It's a race, I'm there to win, not listen to tunes.

_______
Bryan

Of course it's 'effing hard, it's IRONMAN!

UFTriGator's picture
Posts
1127
Member
975 days
UFTriGator posted 1 year ago.

I agree with Red. There are so many things to concentrate on during a race, I don't know how you'd really be able to listen to music and still race effectively. I also think you should train like you race, so I don't listen to music when I'm working out either (except lifting, but there's no bench press in a triathlon!)

______________________________________________
-Matt
Not fast enough.

beads1985's picture
Posts
4914
Member
1717 days
beads1985 posted 1 year ago.

NateDawgK2;57903 wrote:
personally, I prefer to listen to music - at all times
I understand the safety concerns on the bike

but I think its stupid to not allow headphones during the run, whats the sense in that
show me a running race that doesnt allow headphones; every foot race I have ever been in I wore headphones, and I survived without getting run over, trampled or spontenously combusting

I dont use them riding though, although I would like too, its too dangerous to not hear cars, and if you are in a group not hear the other riders; this past summer I was riding with my g/f and her brother, and he was using an ipod with only one headphone in so he could still hear, and he didnt hear me tell him when to make a turn, so he rode off in the wrong direction for about a mile before I chased him down

has anyone seen the new pearl izumi vertex cycing shorts, with the built in player
like or not, people are going to listen while they ride, and the companies take notice

but I do think headphones should be allowed on the run
just my 2 cents

I would make sure you read the rules and regs at any race.
If it is certified by any racing association (USATF, USAT etc..)
it certainly prohibits headphones(amongst other things)
If it is insured(which most races are) it also prohibit headphones.

Most of them advise of penalties for disregarding this rule.
However,the race officials may not catch you, or it may not be strongly enforced.

You and many other people disregard the rule at your own risk. They include it for our safety as a competitor.
If they don't they are liable for any injuries sustained.

Nate - as a lawyer you should realize the issue from a liability and insurance standpoint, even if you choose to ignore it as a safety concern and regard it as "Stupid"

Nothing to it, but to do it

Anton's picture
Posts
2936
Member
1358 days
Anton posted 1 year ago.

I love it! I am going to buy a pair on cycling shorts with the "built in player" Get smacked by a car while on the bike listening to music...then sue the pants off of Pearl Izumi company for promoting the use of MP3 players while biking...that way I can take the rest of my life off and race hand cranks! (Total sarcasm)
I just love folks that think the rules don't apply to them. (More sarcasm.)

"What would life be if we had no courage to attempt anything?" - Vincent Van Gogh
My Blog: http://agingsuperhero.blogspot.com

beads1985's picture
Posts
4914
Member
1717 days
beads1985 posted 1 year ago.

Anton;57959 wrote:
I love it! I am going to buy a pair on cycling shorts with the "built in player" Get smacked by a car while on the bike listening to music...then sue the pants off of Pearl Izumi company for promoting the use of MP3 players while biking...that way I can take the rest of my life off and race hand cranks! (Total sarcasm)
I just love folks that think the rules don't apply to them. (More sarcasm.)

You? Sarcastic?? No? :D

Nothing to it, but to do it

PJT's picture
Posts
1008
Member
1194 days
PJT posted 1 year ago.

I wonder if those PI shorts come with a lengthy disclaimer about how they are for indoor use only, etc. etc.

We seem to get into this debate every few months at Trifuel, but I'll rehash my own position:

1. No headphones for me in races. Even when it's permitted by the rules, I'd rather pay attention to the race.

2. No headphones ever while biking outside. Too dangerous where I live, and illegal in some places to boot.

3. Sometimes headphones for running. Before longer distance stuff, though, I'll be sure to ditch them for several training sessions to work on the mental toughness.

Tikal Dog's picture
Posts
1040
Member
1387 days
Tikal Dog posted 1 year ago.

Anton;57959 wrote:
I love it! I am going to buy a pair on cycling shorts with the "built in player" Get smacked by a car while on the bike listening to music...then sue the pants off of Pearl Izumi company for promoting the use of MP3 players while biking...that way I can take the rest of my life off and race hand cranks! (Total sarcasm)
I just love folks that think the rules don't apply to them. (More sarcasm.)

Anton, if you do that please remember your dear friends here at Trifuel and buy us all P3Cs after you get all that money ;) :D

Hyperactive Trifueler!!!! (I refuse to let the status go :p)

brittda's picture
Posts
1768
Member
1397 days
brittda posted 1 year ago.

NateDawgK2;57903 wrote:
personally, I prefer to listen to music - at all times
I understand the safety concerns on the bike

but I think its stupid to not allow headphones during the run, whats the sense in that
show me a running race that doesnt allow headphones; every foot race I have ever been in I wore headphones, and I survived without getting run over, trampled or spontenously combusting

I dont use them riding though, although I would like too, its too dangerous to not hear cars, and if you are in a group not hear the other riders; this past summer I was riding with my g/f and her brother, and he was using an ipod with only one headphone in so he could still hear, and he didnt hear me tell him when to make a turn, so he rode off in the wrong direction for about a mile before I chased him down

has anyone seen the new pearl izumi vertex cycing shorts, with the built in player
like or not, people are going to listen while they ride, and the companies take notice

but I do think headphones should be allowed on the run
just my 2 cents

well one reason for not allowing them on the run is in many races (ie an Ironman) the road is not closed to cars, and you run on the shoulder. This can be a problem for hearing cars, emergency vehicles, people directing traffic(or you) etc. It becomes even more dangerous if you are out when it gets dark .

azstinger11's picture
Posts
451
Member
731 days
azstinger11 posted 1 year ago.

Here in Tucson I would never even think about riding with my iPod, way to many ignorant drivers. However I do run with my iPod even when im running on the side walk, i just run paranoid (ie always checking my shoulder, turning music off/down near intersections, that kinda stuff). If I'm the gym that thing is also pretty much glued to my side, buts thats just me and what do i know I haven't even done a tri yet:p

-----------------------------------------------
Base 1 (Week 2, 16.5hrs)
Check out my blog!

Homebrewermike's picture
Posts
134
Member
1040 days
Homebrewermike posted 1 year ago.

I wear them all the time in solo training. In all 3 sports. I especially like them for long boring pool swims. It's not fair to generalize that everyone with headphones on cannot hear the traffic. I have the volume low enough on the bike that I can carry on a conversation and also hear traffic. I also wear a mirror and and a RoadID. I think the music helps me focus.

The headphones also help keep the noise of the wind down which can be really annoying after several hours. I usually stop using them a couple weeks before any event that doesn't allow them so that I can get used to not having them on. I wouldn't want to race with them on because I wouldn't want to miss out on the whole experience. I might reconsider that though when I try the 50k and 50 mile run distances.

Red5's picture
Posts
736
Member
887 days
Red5 posted 1 year ago.

If anyone chooses to wear headphones training that's their call. I wear them when running. I wouldn't presume to be able to make a valid agrument that they don't interfere with one's ability to hear traffic. Of course they do, to what extent is variable, but you can't make the case that they are just as safe as not wearing them. They should never be allowed in races.

_______
Bryan

Of course it's 'effing hard, it's IRONMAN!