Training Question/Advice
Here's a link to a trifuel article on the topic of your first question: http://www.trifuel.com/triathlon/triathlon-training/aerobic-base-training-going-slower-to-get-faster-001091.php
As to your second question, yes, I think it is very difficult to rein in the pace on both bike and run to train at base intensity. This is especially true if you have training partners who have different fitness levels. It helps to run alone, and set an alarm on your HRM if you need to. On the bike, I do most of my base building on the trainer, and use the Spinervals aero base builders DVDs and a HRM. In both sports, base building lends itself to really concentrating on form--which will help you in other ways (economy, injury prevention) in the long term.
Here is what a pro says about training below your AeT and what it is:
http://www.markallenonline.com/Base.asp
And to answer the second part of your question, is it hard? Hell ya. It is tough to keep the pace/HR down. Mostly mentally but if you work it as high frequency and volume of running you will see great benefits to your training. Remember freq is the key, then work up the volume but listen to the body foremost. Good luck!
BBB
There are no excuses - so don't look for them. As a product of your own choices, you directly determine your life outcomes.
Don't think, just do.
My Blog
The experts have already chimmed in with reasoning...
but YES IT IS HARD!! It is one of the hardest things for me. I'm still working on it... :/
Training at your max aerobic HR will teach your body to burn fat for fuel. That along with recruiting more slow twitch muscle fibers is the main physio benefit. At least as I understand it. What I've noticed is that even training at these lower heart rates really fatigues my legs. Especially running for more than 60-90 minutes. And yeah the mental side is tough too. Having little old ladies pass you is hard on the ego. My advise? Run in the dark so nobody can see you! :P
"Swim smart, ride strong, run tough" - Gordo Byrn
....And yeah the mental side is tough too. Having little old ladies pass you is hard on the ego. My advise? Run in the dark so nobody can see you! :P
Here, here!
BBB
There are no excuses - so don't look for them. As a product of your own choices, you directly determine your life outcomes.
Don't think, just do.
My Blog
If the slow pace get's to you, try increasing your cadence. It will give you something to work on and will improve your efficiency and running economy. Try and get to 90 strides per min. it's tough!
_______
Bryan
Of course it's 'effing hard, it's IRONMAN!
Red -- do you have any tips for increasing cadence without increasing pace? I believe my stride length is pretty good (I'm landing under me, etc) and find that when I try for a faster cadence I end up going faster and upping HR.
What about hills? Especially on the bike. I live in a pretty hilly area and it is almost impossible to go more than a few miles in any direction without going up or down a good sized hill. So when I try to go for a base pace ride of any length it will involve numerous climbs. No matter what I find it hard to keep the HR down, even if I just spin up the hills in my biggest gear.
________________________________________________
2008 Main Races:
VA Beach Shamrock Marathon
Desoto TTT
WV Mountaineer HIM
IM Wisconsin
When I'm running, for the hills I often have to just walk them. On the bike I just back way off, and get up them as easily as possible. And then I make sure once over the hill I keep it very easy to keep HR down or to drop it if it has gotten too high.
Red -- do you have any tips for increasing cadence without increasing pace? I believe my stride length is pretty good (I'm landing under me, etc) and find that when I try for a faster cadence I end up going faster and upping HR.
That's exactly right, Kiyllee, it is difficult to keep your HR down while increasing cadence. Try keeping your body very upright and do the "lead from your hips" trick, as if you had a rope around your waist pulling you forward. Also, really try and kick up your heals, which again helps shorten the stride and forces you to land directly above your feet. One more, almost try and scrape you feet backward after you land, it help eliminate any up/down bouncing and gives you more forward. When I combine these elements, I can usually settle down my HR but I still am stuck at around 85, so I'm still working on it, too :).
_______
Bryan
Of course it's 'effing hard, it's IRONMAN!
What about hills? Especially on the bike. I live in a pretty hilly area and it is almost impossible to go more than a few miles in any direction without going up or down a good sized hill. So when I try to go for a base pace ride of any length it will involve numerous climbs. No matter what I find it hard to keep the HR down, even if I just spin up the hills in my biggest gear.
get ready to have grandmas w baskets pass you as well till things improve. pushing a big gear up hill is good for muscular strength, but try and ride 50-60rpm if you can; seated. If not do the best you can by keeping the HR at, below or "just" above your bike AeT (i.e., low Z2).
BBB
There are no excuses - so don't look for them. As a product of your own choices, you directly determine your life outcomes.
Don't think, just do.
My Blog
BBB is right on the bike and hills. Just sit up and ride nice and even and you should be able to settle your HR. If it's REALLY steep, you may not have the option, but for every uphill there is a downhill where you can allow you HR to recover and you should still average out for the ride a'ok. :) I often do intervals of 12 min at AeT follwoed by 2min of easy spinning, four sets. It's good to get your HR down for a short period and then bring it back up again.
_______
Bryan
Of course it's 'effing hard, it's IRONMAN!
Thank you to everyone who responded. I am glad to see that I am not the only one who was having trouble with the slow pace. As I can tell from reading posts, a lot of people in here have a strong competitive streak, like myself, and the fact that you have been able to swallow the pride and take it easy gives me faith that I can keep it up.
On a related note, how long should my runs/rides be during the build phase, in terms of time as opposed to miles?
Thanks again for all the help.
That's going to be very dependent on what you are training for, when are your events, what is your current fitness level, ect. You really want to get an hour-1.5 hours per session on the bike or run in these zones to get some benefit and go a little longer on the weekends when you have more time, but again, that's just a geuss without knowing you.
_______
Bryan
Of course it's 'effing hard, it's IRONMAN!
Of course you can follow my plan...start slow and taper off!
It is maddenigly hard to keep it low and slow sometimes but it pays huge rewards later...hard for many folks in the age of instant gratification and ego blather.
"What would life be if we had no courage to attempt anything?" - Vincent Van Gogh
My Blog: http://agingsuperhero.blogspot.com
Anyone out there have suggestions for building a good aerobic run base for us larger runners with little running background, crappy mechanics and a bad knee?
Going below a certain cadence (for me anyway) is a disaster. My form falls apart, I am beating my joints up but not really going anywhere and my heart rate doesn’t really stay down that much. I can walk, but then my heart rate goes too low. I have tried the run-walk-run-walk thing, but that gets frustrating. I am dedicating the winter months solely to improving my running, since building a bike base is pretty easy for me. I am doing around 25-28 miles per week spread over 4 days (M-W-F-Sa) with 1 day dedicated to speedwork and 1 day LSD. Right now I only race Sprint and Oly but want to add a Half next year (maybe a full IM once science perfects the bionic knee replacement).:D
Thanks, T
Depending on the kind of speed work you are doing(intervals?fartlek? Yassos?),I'd lay off of it for awhile and just do long STEADY distance. give your self the winter months and about 10 to 12 weeks out from your first race start with the speed work.
Monday- steady and short. Wednesday- longer and add in some fartlek if you want. Friday-short then Saturday...long.
The sad part about biomechanics is that sometimes we are just not built for some things as much as we love them,they rip us up.
"What would life be if we had no courage to attempt anything?" - Vincent Van Gogh
My Blog: http://agingsuperhero.blogspot.com
Anyone out there have suggestions for building a good aerobic run base for us larger runners with little running background, crappy mechanics and a bad knee?
T- I used to be a larger runner, 6' at 215, and from my own experience I know that I used to run with my whole body-- everything moving, flailing, big strides and bouncing up and down alot. It seems to me that it took all that action just to keep me going forward; hard on the joints too because there was no controlled movement.
Last winter I worked on reducing all unecessary arm and torso movement, shorter and closer to the ground strides and eliminating that bouncy up and down movement. I did all of this with slow MRH runs, focusing only on mechanics and breathing. I put in about 12 weeks just working it out, slow gets to be kind of zen like after awhile, nothing but stride and breathing.
Anyway, not sure if any of this applies to you, just an observation from a used to be larger guy.
Sorry I hijacked your thread Cardinal.
john
Pain is inevitable. Suffering is optional.
Anyone out there have suggestions for building a good aerobic run base for us larger runners with little running background, crappy mechanics and a bad knee?
T- I used to be a larger runner, 6' at 215, and from my own experience I know that I used to run with my whole body-- everything moving, flailing, big strides and bouncing up and down alot. It seems to me that it took all that action just to keep me going forward; hard on the joints too because there was no controlled movement.
Last winter I worked on reducing all unecessary arm and torso movement, shorter and closer to the ground strides and eliminating that bouncy up and down movement. I did all of this with slow MRH runs, focusing only on mechanics and breathing. I put in about 12 weeks just working it out, slow gets to be kind of zen like after awhile, nothing but stride and breathing.
Anyway, not sure if any of this applies to you, just an observation from a used to be larger guy.
Sorry I hijacked your thread Cardinal.
john
Pain is inevitable. Suffering is optional.
No worries, I have no problem with whatever meandering route this thread takes, as I've noticed that no matter what way any post goes, it usually ends up with some useful information.
I actually have a follow up question. When working on base training and attempting to keep HR in aerobic zone, does that mean that it is not a good idea to engage in activities that would elevate your HR above the zone but not with any training goal in mind (i.e. basketball or the like)?
Thanks.
Phil Mafftone says that anaerobic activity should be curbed during this period. Read this:
http://www.rrca.org/resources/articles/slowdown.html
He says:
In addition, an aerobic base period is devoid of weight training, since lifting is also an anaerobic workout.
There may be several reasons why anaerobic workouts can inhibit aerobic base building:
Anaerobic training can decrease the number of aerobic muscle fibers, sometimes significantly. This can happen in just a few short weeks of higher heart rate training.
The lactic acid produced during anaerobic training may inhibit the aerobic muscle enzymes necessary for building an aerobic base.
Anaerobic training raises your respiratory quotient. This means the percentage of energy derived from sugar increases and fat burning decreases. In time, this may force more anaerobic metabolism and less aerobic function.
Stress can also inhibit the aerobic system. Stress is nearly synonymous with anaerobic training. Excess stress raises cortisol levels, which ultimately increases insulin levels, inhibiting fat burning and increasing sugar usage. This promotes anaerobic metabolism and inhibits aerobic activity.
BBB
There are no excuses - so don't look for them. As a product of your own choices, you directly determine your life outcomes.
Don't think, just do.
My Blog
good to know BBB... thanks!
Guess I should actually start listening to the HRM instead of just wearing it... *sigh*
IMO... activities at or above max aerobic HR like lifting weights or playing basketball, raquetball etc for 60min or less a couple times a week shouldn't hurt you. Just my opinion. And BBB knows I respect his views completely. Right LM? :P
As for building base in larger guys, I'm 6-4 and have gone from 200lbs to 175lbs (been 175 for 3 or 4 years now). My advise is just run. Go slow at your max aerobic HR. Keep the frequency up all winter and then start some speed work in the early spring once a week.
"Swim smart, ride strong, run tough" - Gordo Byrn
Well, actually, thinking about what BBB and TimKC have said... I think I'd still play bball or do whatever it was that I enjoyed anyways in base training... since this year a big part of the goal is keeping it fun. But it's also good to know the effects of that fun on goals. Everything in moderation*, right?
* except tris ;)
IMO... activities at or above max aerobic HR like lifting weights or playing basketball, raquetball etc for 60min or less a couple times a week shouldn't hurt you. Just my opinion. And BBB knows I respect his views completely. Right LM? :PAs for building base in larger guys, I'm 6-4 and have gone from 200lbs to 175lbs (been 175 for 3 or 4 years now). My advise is just run. Go slow at your max aerobic HR. Keep the frequency up all winter and then start some speed work in the early spring once a week.
Yeah, there’s no way I would ever give up pumping iron 3-4 times per week.
I am more of a weightlifter that likes to do triathlons than I am a triathlete that lifts weights.
So TriTim…how’s the weather there in KC.?.:D ..I used to live there, my wife is from Lee Summit.
- T
Yeah I'm more of a triathlete/runner that tries to lift weights. hehe
I actually live in LS. We got 8+ inches of snow yesterday!! Now sunny and 26*F. My sister lives in Phx and my folks have a winter home there too.
"Swim smart, ride strong, run tough" - Gordo Byrn






I have done a few tri's and in training have relied mostly on athletic ability and time with each of the disciplines (i.e. no real rhyme or reason to a training session). I have decided that for the upcoming season that I am going to try and focus on specific areas and follow the base build, speed, etc... periods. My question is this... can someone explain to me the physiological benefit of running at a pace that will keep the HR down below a specific percentage? Also, for those that train this way, have you also found it hard to rein yourself in and keep the pace slow enough to keep the HR down while fighting the urge to run faster?
Thanks for all the advice going forward.