Quantcast

The Truth about Sport Bars

Winters27's picture
Posts
15
Member
939 days
started by Winters27 on May 10, 2006

I love sport/energy bars.

Generally when I am training, I'll eat one or two everyday.

But I can''t help but wonder: Aren't they basically candy bars?
Candy bars with a splash of added protien and nutrients.

And isn't it true that just because some element is on the nurtition label it doesn't mean your body is accessing and utilizing it?

Are there any nutritionists or chemists out there who can shed light?

sldotter's picture
Posts
208
Member
1193 days
sldotter posted 2 years ago.

energy comes from fat, carb and protein so my guess is that you could technically call any food product an energy food product. Snickers bar could be an energy bar. Calories for energy.

Trevor Douglas YOU ARE AN IRONMAN!

Triguy98's picture
Posts
2455
Member
1330 days
Triguy98 posted 2 years ago.

And here I thought you were going to rip on sports bars. Or profess your love for them... and the wings and beer they serve... mmmm

Chicken wing & beer flavored energy bars! Yum!

Life is short. Play hard and get dirty doing it.

MadAustinite's picture
Posts
37
Member
961 days
MadAustinite posted 2 years ago.

Triguy98 wrote:

Chicken wing & beer flavored energy bars! Yum!

haha yes!!! hmmm i can feel an idea and a production method coming on

Marines
Semper FI
Pain is a necessity in life and only makes one stronger

nyfan21's picture
Posts
327
Member
1301 days
nyfan21 posted 2 years ago.

Winters27 wrote:
I love sport/energy bars.

Generally when I am training, I'll eat one or two everyday.

But I can''t help but wonder: Aren't they basically candy bars?
Candy bars with a splash of added protien and nutrients.

And isn't it true that just because some element is on the nurtition label it doesn't mean your body is accessing and utilizing it?

Are there any nutritionists or chemists out there who can shed light?

They are not Candy bars; look at a "Good BAR" like LEAD BODY BARS. They are high in protien low in sugar and they have good carbs. Don't look at the front of the bars look at what is inside. They are a good quick food.

-Boston

Learn's picture
Posts
94
Member
1153 days
Learn posted 2 years ago.

You know, I just instinctively clicked on this because I misread it as 'The Truth About Sports Bras.'

Then I saw what it was and thought, yeah, I bet a triathlete would be pretty disappointed with the ESPN Zone.

Any now I see you are talking about. Yeah, bars are a lot of junk. I tend to think that gels are preferable. It's sort of become my habit - and has had good results - to eat a Snickers Marathon bar before 'big' races.

Anton's picture
Posts
2949
Member
1368 days
Anton posted 2 years ago.

Here is an interesting read for all you bar heads!

cspinet.org/nah/12_00/barexam.html

Sure..the info is dated (2000) but it goes along with a number of articles of recent interest that talk about bars as a meal replacement being bad idea.

"What would life be if we had no courage to attempt anything?" - Vincent Van Gogh
My Blog: http://agingsuperhero.blogspot.com

catwood's picture
Posts
849
Member
1488 days
catwood posted 2 years ago.

My opinion about sports bars is that they really aren't great for during training (except for long slow bike rides) or especially not during racing. The fat, fiber, and protein just wreak havoc on my digestive system...

When I eat sports bars its generally after a workout if I don't have time for a proper meal or as a snack before a morning workout (real breakfast after) if that's the only thing I have. Even then I only eat chocolate peppermint luna bars because those are the only ones that taste good.

I tend to think of them more as backpacking food or food for really long slow bike rides.

RV's picture
Posts
3354
Member
1412 days
RV posted 2 years ago.

Ya, I like sportsbars more for recovery - especially since some have a good amount of protein. I stick to gels during training and racing. They are fine when short on time for a regular meal.

RV

It takes a long time to get good. - Scott Molina
Slow is smooth; smooth is fast. - Rich Strauss

dr_rios_ec's picture
Posts
815
Member
1168 days
dr_rios_ec posted 2 years ago.

Anton wrote:
Here is an interesting read for all you bar heads!

cspinet.org/nah/12_00/barexam.html

Sure..the info is dated (2000) but it goes along with a number of articles of recent interest that talk about bars as a meal replacement being bad idea.

Very interesting article, with great good points to think and know about...
Now, in my personal opinion, I use them as a quick snack, if I am on a rush....or as a recovery part of my meal, but never during trainning or racing...

-Santiago
"Man!! Defeat is worse than dying, cause´you have to live with it" -My Dad
"It ain´t about how hard you can hit...it is how hard you can get hit and keep moving forward"-Rocky Balboa

bpsgson's picture
Posts
9
Member
1296 days
bpsgson posted 2 years ago.

Our tri club recently had the Queen of Kona, Paula Newby Fraser as a guest who told us that her favorite race bar was a Twix (no joke). Despite the fact that she was long sponsored by MetRx, she would hide her twix bars in the MetRx wrappers! Tough to argue with the champ!

BigGus's picture
Posts
132
Member
677 days
BigGus posted 1 year ago.

bpsgson;44780 wrote:
Our tri club recently had the Queen of Kona, Paula Newby Fraser as a guest who told us that her favorite race bar was a Twix (no joke). Despite the fact that she was long sponsored by MetRx, she would hide her twix bars in the MetRx wrappers! Tough to argue with the champ!

George Costanza: "It was a Twix, they were all Twix, it was a setup, and you ruined it, AAAAAAAHHHH!!!!!!!!"

BigGus's picture
Posts
132
Member
677 days
BigGus posted 1 year ago.

Bars are very high in calories. If you are an ectomorph that loses weight if you don't eat regularly, then go for it. Otherwise, the best and most inexpensive portable food is the banana. They even sell them in convinence stores and gas stations now. I eat so many that when I walk the back of my hands drag on the ground.

Airborne's picture
Posts
149
Member
1424 days
Airborne posted 1 year ago.

BigGus;61545 wrote:
Bars are very high in calories. If you are an ectomorph that loses weight if you don't eat regularly, then go for it. Otherwise, the best and most inexpensive portable food is the banana. They even sell them in convinence stores and gas stations now. I eat so many that when I walk the back of my hands drag on the ground.

I disagree. Frankly, I don't understand the recent admonition of sports bars as bad nutrition. I have used them for the last year or so with great success. The caloric content of the bar is irrelevant as long as your total daily intake remains constant. Therefore, if you eat a 250-calorie Clif bar between breakfast and lunch, simply reduce your lunch meal by 250 calories. That's the method I've been using in the past year, in effect spreading out my daily caloric intake. I'll usually eat one or two bars per day, like Winters27. In the last year, using this method, I've arrived at my ideal race weight, gotten leaner and stronger, dropped 20 minutes off my marathon PR, and am ready to take on the Ironman in April. I haven't plateaued yet, and continue to improve.

After reading warnings from various sources that bars aren't optimal nutrition, I tried going the "fruits/veggies/protein only" route for my snacks, and it just didn't work for me. Getting the same nutrition as a nice compact Clif bar would require something like: one apple, one banana, one slice of lean meat, AND a handful of peanuts. Yikes! The Clif bar does the job for me without making me feel all bloated. Of course, the nutrition on the back is important -- a bar with 5g fat and 1.5g sat fat is superior to a bar with 5g fat and 4.5g sat fat. My favorites are Clif, Odwalla, and Lara. Good combination of good fats, protein, carbs, and fiber.

I still love my fruits & veggies, and eat them with most meals, but my tweener meals will continue to be bars; they work for me.

fitnessman03's picture
Posts
79
Member
675 days
fitnessman03 posted 1 year ago.

Sports bars are a supplement to a healthy diet. Of course you shouldn't live off of them, but they can help you when you need them. Long workouts, on the go, if you don't have time to prepare something, there are times for them. Yes, I know, some are packed with sugars and fat, you just have to make choices to pick the best and most nutritional ones and know when to eat them. Depending on your goals and training intensities will determine if and when you should be consuming these bars.

Back in the day, cycylists would eat snickers for energy. You have your peanuts, caramel, nugget, and chocolate for energy, good enough eehh!??

I have also been on long rides where guys pick up a drumstick ice cream in the middle of the ride. I thought it was the weirdest thing I have ever seen. But, it kind of made sense if you are looking for quick energy, right?

Justin Levine
www.justintrain.com
"Be excited to live and enjoy every day to the fullest!"

deepbluex's picture
Posts
693
Member
1152 days
deepbluex posted 1 year ago.

This might sound really gross to many of you but what if there was a "savory" bar out there? I don't have much of a sweet tooth and generally prefer a more salty type of snack. I guess a pretzel is closer to a "savory bar" than anything but I wish that option did exist out there. As much as I enjoy chocolate, sometimes it's not quite the flavor that I am wanting when working out and starting to get hungry.

Maybe I should just pack some eggrolls for my longer rides.

Ironmom's picture
Posts
634
Member
732 days
Ironmom posted 1 year ago.

deepbluex;61601 wrote:
This might sound really gross to many of you but what if there was a "savory" bar out there? I don't have much of a sweet tooth and generally prefer a more salty type of snack. I guess a pretzel is closer to a "savory bar" than anything but I wish that option did exist out there. As much as I enjoy chocolate, sometimes it's not quite the flavor that I am wanting when working out and starting to get hungry.

Maybe I should just pack some eggrolls for my longer rides.

I ran into a gal on the IMFL course who had KFC mashed potatoes in a pastry tube taped to her frame. After several hours of sugary drinks and gels, those mashed potatoes looked goooooood.

There is a savory nut bar out there, it's like a salty almond and peanut bar, can't remember what it's called right now though...

Blue Skies, -Robin-
http://ironmom.blogspot.com/

Ironmom's picture
Posts
634
Member
732 days
Ironmom posted 1 year ago.

Learn;44649 wrote:
You know, I just instinctively clicked on this because I misread it as 'The Truth About Sports Bras.'

Yes, and one should never EVER substitute a Snickers for a Sports Bra...

Blue Skies, -Robin-
http://ironmom.blogspot.com/

kylie's picture
Posts
4495
Member
1644 days
kylie posted 1 year ago.

Sometimes I use Take 5 candy bars during races (peanuts, peanut butter, pretzels, caramel, chocolate). For my first IM I was using bars I didn't like (my gut isn't picky, just my tastebuds). And chopped into pieces the same size I never knew with a blind grab if I'd get yummy Take5 or yucky bar. But either one I'd eat, and then 20 minutes later play that lotto again. I really liked that combo of salty with the pretzels. I've also just used choc or yogurt covered pretzels during adv races.

Ironmom's picture
Posts
634
Member
732 days
Ironmom posted 1 year ago.

I found the name of those nut/pretzel bars, they're Mojo bars made by Clifbar: http://www.clifbar.com/eat/eat.cfm?location=mojo They're not real sweet, and pretty salty/nutty.

Blue Skies, -Robin-
http://ironmom.blogspot.com/

chavi's picture
Posts
67
Member
1022 days
chavi posted 1 year ago.

I agree with the posts made that some bars are a good supplement for mid-meal snacks. I use Aussie Bodies protein bars because of the whey protein they use. Im not sure if you can get these in the US though.

During training, Ive used gatorade, gels and powerbars and once tried small sandwiches with pickles and ketchup for my longest ride ever of 70km.

I like gatorade but it is a bit sweet and by the end of the session all I can think about it water and brushing my teeth.

Gels are okay but personally hate the wrapping and the waste. Id rather make my own snacks and save money, whilst doing my bit for the environment. A little kodak film container kept in a pouch at the front of your bike or in your shirt pocket with home made sludge is a creative option. Ofcourse, you have to set aside the time to make the sludge and fill up the containers.

Or make your own bars. There are some great posts on this site on home made recipes that I have yet to try. I usually just through whatever I have together and see what happens. My Mum offers great feedback on my experiments. :D

Just trial and error as they say.

chavi

"Commitment means struggle, it means effort and always sacrifice".