Help me pick a wheelset! Real info please.
yep tubulars are the way to go. they give a mich better ride than clinchers. that said you must be aware, if you get a flat you need to carry a spare tubular to replace it and then you need to take it easy cos the glue is not 100% bonded. They go flat over night so you need to pump them up the morning of the race. There are more Pros that cons for tubulars. i only race on tubulars but train on clinchers.
Speed Kills. Strength Punishes
they give a mich better ride than clinchers.
Could you explain this? I've never ridden tubulars, but have ridden some great clinchers, so I'm not sure of the benefits of tubulars.
Could you explain this? I've never ridden tubulars, but have ridden some great clinchers, so I'm not sure of the benefits of tubulars.
OK clinchers have the innertube on the rim then the tire over the top, the tubular tire is a tire with a tube already encased in it, tubulars are also called singls.
You need to have a good frame and a good set of wheels before you can truly bring out the feel of a tubular tire. Clinchers have come a long way but i still feel tubulars make you one with the road. it's personal choice really.
The rolling resistance of a tubular tire is less than that of a clincher tire because tubular tires can be inflated to much higher pressures than clincher tires. Some brands go as high as 220 psi(i dont want to be near it when it bursts!)
Tubular tires weigh less than clincher tires. this is moot because unless you have a support team, you're going to have to carry an extra tubular tire in case of a flat.
Tubular rims weigh less than clincher rims - no bead just rim.
Tubular tires accelerate faster because they have a lower rotational mass of the tire and the rim (it's minimal i know but any advantage is a good one).
In acceleration the most signifigant component is the the mass on the edge of the rotational body. The lighter the weight on this outside diameter the less force needed to accelerate the wheel and hence the bike........(go engineer boy!)
Finally they are more puncture resistant because dirt and glass cant get under the bead and in to the tube like in clinchers. Tubular inners are often made of latex and kevlar which has a better elasticity than clinchers. The big difference is the TPI count. TPI stands for threads per inch meaning how many threads to a one inch length of casing. the higher the TPI the better the puncture resistance vittoira makes tires with TPI's of 20-220 (i think)
So mabye that either helps of confuses you. :confused:
Speed Kills. Strength Punishes
just playing devil's advocate.. but wouldn't a higher pressure also transfer more road vibration?
yeah it'll decrease rolling resistance, but at what cost to "comfort" wich isn't a big deal at 20 miles.. but 112, im lookin for comfort AND decreased rolling resistance...
(Im not saying that sew ups aren't a better choice.. but I'm curious to hear from MORE people who have ridden both and prefer one over the other)
oh and i'd like to hear from people that have ridden both on the same wheel..eg.
HED 3's (both tubular & clincher)
ZIPP 303's (both tubular & clincher)
etc...
because otherwise you're ride could have been made better by switching wheelsets..
As Iron sharpens Iron, so one man sharpens another. proverbs 27:17
[url=http://www.northatlantamultisport.org]
Again.. I don;t want to start one of these treads... but i think i did...
CLINCHERS ATUALLY ROLL BETTER....I've seen the data... the slow twich.com folks are crazy about data.
My coach has a pair of 606's in both clincher and tubular and recomends the clinchers...
Most if not all pros however still use tubulars.... the weight difference in the 606 is near 550 grams.
Yea,, i know carrying a tubular sucks...
i'm still leaning toward the tubulars because of the weight.. hmm. i'm going to ride them i guess.. that's the only way.....
oh yea... and no on rides 220 psi... alteast i hope not.... learn from the road circuit.. 110 ro clinchers on race day, 150-60 on tubs.
I'm also looking at the 606 set right now... and having the same question.
For IM, I'm thinking that having to carry 2 spares (yeah, I'm paranoid) will out-do the weight issues. And I'm also nervous about having to change one.
One particular part of the info about has me curious...
if you get a flat you need to carry a spare tubular to replace it and then you need to take it easy cos the glue is not 100% bonded.
How easy is easy?
Miles of Life --- Powered by MarkyV
Norman Stadler easy......
i mean if your racing Monaco 70.3.... yea watch yourself... because you might fall off a cliff.... but a flat or rolling course.. ehh?
Thanks for the info on tubulars. It all makes sense, but it doesn't convince me to go through the hassle of learning how to and repeatedly gluing on the tires (personal choice). I'd rather do 1 extra 100mile ride before my IM to squash the "benefit" of tubulars. Oh and Vredestein makes a clincher than can be pumped to 175 psi. It's the Vresdestein Fortezza Tri Comp. I've used them in a Half as well as all the training for that race and they worked great.
How easy is easy?
EASY like dont fly round a corner because when you get out the other side you wont have a tire...............just a rim and on a fancy pair of 606's that will just about ruin them. Easy is as easy as you want, i personally dont want to ruin my race wheels so i take it easy but thats me. whatever works for you is best.
Speed Kills. Strength Punishes
Thanks Blake... that basically would mean I wouldn't have to worry. :)
Iron Man -- I was trying to get at more of a factual answer... like what kind of speed? I'm slow, so my fast could be someone else's easy. "Easy is as easy as you want" doesn't really help. Of course I wouldn't be wanting to ruin race wheels, but in order to not do that I have to know what is being careful for them. And if it meant "go less than 12 mph after a flat" I would get other race wheels. When I race I want to go as fast as I can, and I don't want a flat at mile 10 of my IM to mean I'm basically screwed. "Whatever works for you" doesn't really tell me the limits of that type of tire, which is what I'm trying to learn.
Miles of Life --- Powered by MarkyV
Hmm... well the thing is it's not an exact science... I can't say, oh at "23mph your done." It's more of a handling skill. If you every go downhill you can tell at what point turning becomes "to sharp".... it's something like that... when a tire is not fully gued onto a tubular rim, the primary force holding it on is the tire pressure itself, and the glue secondary.... this is usually the other way around. When it's gled down well you can really push your limits, just like with a clincher. Cornering is a bit more responsive on a tubular. However, if you want to go the route of the clinchers, tufo makes "tubular clinchers" which i've seen quite a few folks swear by. They're pricey, but really good for tri.... other good tires are the ones with higher TPI, (threadcount) like Vittoria, and Conti, but easy because some of them really wear out quick. Tubulars are a bit more work to put on... not to much more though and that whole "takes alot of time thisg" is a myth... once you get the hang of it you can change one just as quick as a clincher. you just have to be careful. I'd go all out for tubs, because you glue one a pair and hope they excel... my recomendation is the Conti Competition... their pricey, but i wouldn't take chances. Some folks will tell you to go cheaper... but that;s just my 2 cents... hope this helps a bit...
in the realistic end, if you have 2 lbs to shead, then th weight difference dosen't reallly justify. ride what you like and trust.. i'm exprementing with the tubular thing because i've seen good feedback nd i'm looking into it.
Makes sense.
Can you feel during the ride what is good and back on a changed tubular, or is it more once it falls of then you know?
Miles of Life --- Powered by MarkyV



Alright... so i've made up my mind... I'm saving my pennies for a Zipp 606 set... not just Clincher or Tubular...
NOW HOLD ON! I'm not trying to start up one of "those" threads, but i'm asking of who uses what...
I'm leaning towards the tubulars, but i just saw picks of the new Zipp Disc Clincher, and am seeing alot more clinchers out there! WTF.. I know Campy is doing carbon clincher rims, but by the time that comes around i'll sell the 606 and get some newer amazing must have crack habit thing.
Anyway, I'm ranting... should I just shut up and go Tubular? Just looking for words of wisdom... hell if i gotta shell out 1100 for them (Ebay Kids) i'd like to do it right.
THX
www.wiiings.blogspot.com
www.rutgerscycling.com