Quantcast

avoid dairy products?

gato's picture
Posts
12
Member
1483 days
started by gato on September 30, 2005

A friend recommend me to avoid dairy products (milk, yogurth, cheese, etc); he said his performance was improved dramatically since he made this change in his diet.
I know dairy products as a good source of protein and calcium, but now I don't know if I should avoid them. :confused:

I would appreciate any comment about this. :rolleyes:

catwood's picture
Posts
849
Member
1489 days
catwood posted 3 years ago.

That sound's pretty ridiculous to me... Dairy products are such a great source of lean protein (to get the c-p-f ratio right without too much fat and tofu is just :eek: ) I can't imagine avoiding them. Some people avoid them pre-race because they screw with their digestive systems, but that's totally individual. When I am at home (summer = tri-season), I drink about a half gallon of milk a day and sometimes I even have milk or yogurt for an early pre-race breakfast and I'm sure it hasn't slowed me down. And if it has, which I sincerely doubt, my slowness because of too little training totally outweighs it...

There are plenty of other things that triathletes should eat carefully in out diets and dairy (at least lean dairy) should not be one of them unless you're a vegan or something. Some of everything in a calculated moderation is the way to go. I would always be skeptical if someone tells me to avoid an entire food group. Even if they tell me to avoid the junk food group because highly refined sugars are exactly what you should eat or drink while actaully training and racing. Also, if you are training a lot, sometimes it is hard to get all the calories that you need without some calorie dense foods.

If you are interested in sports nutrition or plan on making drastic changes to your diet to improve your athletic performance, I recommend reading Chris Carmichael's Food for Fitness or Monique Ryan's Sports Nutrition for Endurance Athletes first.

gato's picture
Posts
12
Member
1483 days
gato posted 3 years ago.

Thank you, Catwood. Besides the reasons you gave me, I was kind of scary because I like dairy a lot!!!

christri25's picture
Posts
1355
Member
1396 days
christri25 posted 3 years ago.

cat ~ thanks for bringing reason ! i cut the meat out but dairy products I still use and that did sound kind of bizarre.

Chris

``It's not as if I'm going to sit around and be a fat slob,''
Lance Armstrong 2005

trimedic's picture
Posts
212
Member
1641 days
trimedic posted 3 years ago.

Isn't dairy on the food piramid. Millions of dietitians can't be wrong!!! Everything in moderation is my moto. As long as your system can tolerate diary, eat it. Calcium, protien...it's all good. I have to watch the quantities I eat and some of the forms I take dairy in because I am some what lactose intolerant but I don't know how I would get most of my protien without dairy.

dr_rios_ec's picture
Posts
815
Member
1169 days
dr_rios_ec posted 3 years ago.

Saludos Gato!!!
I can no remember something so "nonsense" ike the advice someone gave to you to avoid milk, yougurt and stuff...
Man...those are great sources of energy...and protein...besides they are absolutly delicious...
But!!!...there is always a but...
If you feel your stomach upsetc...bloated...and maybe some diarrea, maybe you are lactose intolerant...something really common these days...
There are some solutions for that...
1.-Try milk with NO LACTOSE...taste good...and has almost all waht regular milk has...
2.-Try yougurt...specially Non Fat...it is better tolerated that Milk...
3.-If bloating persist...try some Lactase caps...they are sold over the counter...and they really do wonders...

Get this humble words from the "King of Lactose Intolerance" who happens to be ME! :eek:

Hasta la vista
Santiago Rios MD
a.k.a Flea

-Santiago
"Man!! Defeat is worse than dying, cause´you have to live with it" -My Dad
"It ain´t about how hard you can hit...it is how hard you can get hit and keep moving forward"-Rocky Balboa

Triguy98's picture
Posts
2455
Member
1332 days
Triguy98 posted 3 years ago.

A previous GF had a weightlifting instructor that swore dairy was poison and was the reason for all of man's health issues. Crazy stuff.

Life is short. Play hard and get dirty doing it.

beads1985's picture
Posts
4949
Member
1727 days
beads1985 posted 3 years ago.

Milk and other dairy products provide complex carbs, protein, and calcium, and are quickly absorbed into your digestive system(with exception to those who are lactose intolerant)

Preferably go with one that is low fat or non fat.
They also have organic dairy products if you are concerned about hormone and antibiotic use.

Nothing to it, but to do it

BC Guy's picture
Posts
4
Member
1153 days
BC Guy posted 3 years ago.

I haven't consumed dairy products in any form in almost a year and feel a lot better as a result. Here's an article that may change a few minds about the so-called "benefits" of consuming milk.

http://www.notmilk.com/kradjian.html

Triguy98's picture
Posts
2455
Member
1332 days
Triguy98 posted 3 years ago.

BC Guy wrote:
I haven't consumed dairy products in any form in almost a year and feel a lot better as a result. Here's an article that may change a few minds about the so-called "benefits" of consuming milk.

http://www.notmilk.com/kradjian.html

Is "notmilk.com" not a subsidiary of PETA? Anyone can dig up some "scientific" information and post it as cold hard fact. The unfortunate fact fo the matter is that not all science is pure, nor are all results correct, hence the peer review part of true science. If all these "facts" as stated by this site were, in fact FACTS, we all would be very much aware of the dangers and more information would be present regarding the "poison" that is milk.

Its not a perfect food, but there is no such thing. People the world over have adverse reactions to wide variety of foods, some of which are suggested as protein substitutes by the vegetarian cult.

It's unfortunate that people by into this ramapant misinformation. and attempt to spread it. I'll take my advice from the true and established nutritionists and scientists, thank you very much!

Life is short. Play hard and get dirty doing it.

RV's picture
Posts
3354
Member
1413 days
RV posted 3 years ago.

Glad I had a nice big glass of cold milk to drink to get me through that article. Sheeze.
I suspect anything that wants to eliminate a whole food type - No dairy, no carbs...
Seemed to be a big scare article.
I'll have my milk - thank you.

RV

It takes a long time to get good. - Scott Molina
Slow is smooth; smooth is fast. - Rich Strauss

catwood's picture
Posts
849
Member
1489 days
catwood posted 3 years ago.

I'm sticking to what I said earlier...
I've taken a class in nutrition and have read a few of the sports nutrition books out there.
Milk is good.

dr_rios_ec's picture
Posts
815
Member
1169 days
dr_rios_ec posted 3 years ago.

Very well said TryGuy...
As a health profesional, I truly recomend to everybody, patients, friends, family, and fellow athletes to read carefully and conciously all what is posted in de Web...
As you said TryGuy...there is no such thing as a Wonder Food! or a Magic Drink for athletes...
Is better t read..and read...try...and try...have some expert advice...and then make a choice that fits well our body and system...
And...as RV wrote...
I am also enjoying a cold and told glass of Milk with no lactose..and a couple of pancakes....
You know guys...we need our carbs...tomorrow is Saturday...big day for trainning
Regards

Santiago Rios MD

-Santiago
"Man!! Defeat is worse than dying, cause´you have to live with it" -My Dad
"It ain´t about how hard you can hit...it is how hard you can get hit and keep moving forward"-Rocky Balboa

BC Guy's picture
Posts
4
Member
1153 days
BC Guy posted 3 years ago.

Triguy98 wrote:
Is "notmilk.com" not a subsidiary of PETA? Anyone can dig up some "scientific" information and post it as cold hard fact. !

The letter was not written by PETA, it was written by Robert M. Kradjian, MD
Breast Surgery Chief Division of General Surgery,

Anton's picture
Posts
2954
Member
1369 days
Anton posted 3 years ago.

Heck...I jsut started drinking more milk and feel better and am healing faster than I did when I was avoiding the stuff...
The bottom line is...Find out what works for you! Don't go by what someone tells you to do,find out for yourself. Some can handle milk products fine...others can't. For every opinion there is a counter-point.For every "fact" there is someone who will tell you it's a "lie."
I call it food politics.
Find what works for you...

Have a better one!

"What would life be if we had no courage to attempt anything?" - Vincent Van Gogh
My Blog: http://agingsuperhero.blogspot.com

SundayND's picture
Posts
75
Member
1064 days
SundayND posted 2 years ago.

I am a dairy fool, but was reading an article on Runner'sWorld.com and it mentioned avoiding fruit and dairy (but only pre-workout) so as to avoid bowel issues during your workout. I have since cut those two things out before my AM workouts and 2 hours before later workouts and have not had as many problems.

I agree with the majority here, don't cut out dairy completely. But I think there are some people out there that it just doesn't work for them.

I pity da fool!

thehitman's picture
Posts
806
Member
1391 days
thehitman posted 2 years ago.

SundayND wrote:
.... I agree with the majority here, don't cut out dairy completely. But I think there are some people out there that it just doesn't work for them.

Dairy Products Are the Primary Source of Calcium

My "drink 3 glasses of milk a day" advise is usually in reference to a question about protein intake. But dairy products are also the primary source of calcium for most of us. While we usually just think of calcium as being necessary for "strong bones," it is also an essential electrolyte, and vital for a whole array of bodily functions.

If you avoid dairy products, make sure you find another source for calcium (and Vitamin D).

thehitman

thehitman

“Always do right. This will gratify some people and astonish the rest.” Mark Twain
[/SIZE]

gjpure's picture
Posts
79
Member
1258 days
gjpure posted 2 years ago.

I have heard different opinions about dairy out there. For one, while dairy is a source of protein, it is not the best source in that in many people is does not digest not absorb well. MOST people are slightly lactose intolerante without even realizing it. This is because dairy products such as milk esecially are, from a nutritional standpoint, meant for infants. The combination of calcium and Vitamin D supports their growth. As adults, their are many options to those who either have problems with dairy or believe the infant theory. I know many people dont realize they are intolerant but when they go off the dairy they feel different. My wife used to break out with acne when she had too much dairy. It also makes people bloated and sluggish. Now, I believe in a balanced diet, but everyone has what works for them, or what they thinks works for them. And with all I have read and heard, and the way everyone contradicts each other, it may be safe to conclude that we dont know anything and it is all just a guess anyway.

thehitman's picture
Posts
806
Member
1391 days
thehitman posted 2 years ago.

gjpure wrote:
I have heard different opinions about dairy out there.... (W)ith all I have read and heard, and the way everyone contradicts each other, it may be safe to conclude that we dont know anything and it is all just a guess anyway.

That's one approach to knowledge I hope I never take!

thehitman

thehitman

“Always do right. This will gratify some people and astonish the rest.” Mark Twain
[/SIZE]

bigdogtwo's picture
Posts
131
Member
1198 days
bigdogtwo posted 2 years ago.

The dairy lobby is incredibly powerful. The fact that dairy is included in the food pyramid is not due to needing it in our diet.

Read the chapter on Dairy in "Eat Drink Be Healthy: The Harvard Medical School Guide to Healthy Eating" by Walter C. Willett MD. It says that dairy increases the risk of a number of cancers and doesn't help the overall calcium level in your body (due to the fact that ingesting animal protein leads you to excrete calcium in your urine). Also, most dairy is loaded with fat. Some will say "I only drink skim milk" - but do you eat cheese too? Loaded with fat and cholesterol. Anyway, its a whole chapter on dairy and why you don't need it and why it causes problems. And its from the Harvard Med School - NOT PETA.

Our bodies aren't really designed to drink milk after infancy. Especially not of another species. Dairy is very difficult for us to digest and leads to all sorts of minor health problems - days that you feel sort of "blah" but don't know why. Try giving up all dairy for 3 or 4 weeks and see how you feel. I have plenty of friends and co-workers who have tried going dairy free and feel so much better they have kept with it. I challenge each of you to give up all dairy (its hard dairy is in so much food) for a month and see how you feel.

dr_rios_ec's picture
Posts
815
Member
1169 days
dr_rios_ec posted 2 years ago.

gjpure wrote:
it may be safe to conclude that we dont know anything and it is all just a guess anyway.
:eek:

With all do respect: That is a path in knowledge that I will always try to avoid. Just to name another "nicer" way for example: "Evidence based Medicine" is not based in random guessing

-Santiago
"Man!! Defeat is worse than dying, cause´you have to live with it" -My Dad
"It ain´t about how hard you can hit...it is how hard you can get hit and keep moving forward"-Rocky Balboa

Blitz's picture
Posts
699
Member
1259 days
Blitz posted 2 years ago.

Anyone in the mood for a big bowl of ice cream?

Mmmm I love dairy products! Especially from cows. Have you ever looked closely at the teeth of extreme athletes? If you don't like cow juice, then make sure you take in calcium.

Who needs a man when you have a Kuota Kalibur to wrap your legs around.

ggalvao's picture
Posts
290
Member
1064 days
ggalvao posted 2 years ago.

Blitz wrote:
Anyone in the mood for a big bowl of ice cream?

Mmmm I love dairy products! Especially from cows. Have you ever looked closely at the teeth of extreme athletes? If you don't like cow juice, then make sure you take in calcium.

What do you mean as regarding their teeth?

Blitz's picture
Posts
699
Member
1259 days
Blitz posted 2 years ago.

I mean that some of them look like they have calcium deficiencies, and it's obvious when they smile. One can get plenty of calcium from the plant kingdom, but I prefer eating ice cream.

Blitz

Who needs a man when you have a Kuota Kalibur to wrap your legs around.

thehitman's picture
Posts
806
Member
1391 days
thehitman posted 2 years ago.

bigdogtwo wrote:
The dairy lobby is incredibly powerful. The fact that dairy is included in the food pyramid is not due to needing it in our diet.
Read the chapter on Dairy in "Eat Drink Be Healthy: The Harvard Medical School Guide to Healthy Eating" by Walter C. Willett MD. It says that dairy increases the risk of a number of cancers and doesn't help the overall calcium level in your body (due to the fact that ingesting animal protein leads you to excrete calcium in your urine)...
Try giving up all dairy for 3 or 4 weeks and see how you feel. I have plenty of friends and co-workers who have tried going dairy free and feel so much better they have kept with it. I challenge each of you to give up all dairy (its hard dairy is in so much food) for a month and see how you feel.

bigdogtwo,

If you feel great without dairy, and are able to meet your calcium needs through other means, that's fantastic. I haven't read Dr. Willett's book, but I know its gotten very good reviews, and its now on my list.

An ever increasing number of studies are showing the vital functions calcium and Vitamin D play in our systems, including a study released the other day linking Vitamin D with decreased incidence of colon, breast and ovarian cancers (reviewing 63 previous studies). http://www.latimes.com/features/health/la-he-briefly2.1jan02,1,5840933.story?coll=la-headlines-health

So I'm taking a different approach from the one you suggest. I'm going to take my own advise, and make sure that I drink at least 3 glasses of nonfat milk a day. Perhaps calcium fortified OJ, too, or other calcium supplementation (the absorption rate of calcium appears to be wildly variable, depending on several factors). As a matter of fact, I'm making sure my vitamin and mineral intake, across the board, is where I think it should be. I'll let you know how I feel in a month.

thehitman

“Always do right. This will gratify some people and astonish the rest.” Mark Twain
[/SIZE]

bigdogtwo's picture
Posts
131
Member
1198 days
bigdogtwo posted 2 years ago.

I think the "calcium crisis" in our country is overblown. We are one of the top 3 countries in the world with regard to dairy consumed per capita yet we are also in the top 3 countries in the world in terms of low bone density and osteoporosis.

Why do we have low bone mass? (1) lack of weight bearing exercise, (2) obesity, (3) lack of vitamin D and (4) overconsumption of animal products.

Weight bearing exercise plays a huge role in keeping up bone density. As our nation has become more sedentary and fatter we have exercised less.
Recent studies have shown that Vitamin D deficiency is a bigger link to low bone density that calcium intake levels. We get vitamin D from sunlight. As our skin cancer fears rise and we become more sedentary people are getting less sunlight and lead to vitamin D deficiencies.
Americans are consuming larger and larger amounts of animal protein which leads to reduced calcium absorption by the body due to excreting it out of your urine.

Unlike some vitamins and minerals, calcium from supplements is very effective.

Dairy is linked with weight gain and obesity, heart disease and certain cancers. If you do the research I think you'll find that consuming dairy isn't worth it just for the calcium. You can get the calcium elsewhere.

Hitman-like you I am a lawyer and feel somewhat uneasy not citing everthing I state above. But, this is just a triathlon board and I am not going to take the time. Upon request, however, I will be glad to provide support for the above (and none of it is from PETA - while I don't consume animal products I do have leather seats on my car).

thehitman's picture
Posts
806
Member
1391 days
thehitman posted 2 years ago.

bigdogtwo wrote:
I think the "calcium crisis" in our country is overblown. We are one of the top 3 countries in the world with regard to dairy consumed per capita yet we are also in the top 3 countries in the world in terms of low bone density and osteoporosis.

Why do we have low bone mass? (1) lack of weight bearing exercise, (2) obesity, (3) lack of vitamin D and (4) overconsumption of animal products.

Weight bearing exercise plays a huge role in keeping up bone density. As our nation has become more sedentary and fatter we have exercised less.
Recent studies have shown that Vitamin D deficiency is a bigger link to low bone density that calcium intake levels. We get vitamin D from sunlight. As our skin cancer fears rise and we become more sedentary people are getting less sunlight and lead to vitamin D deficiencies.
Americans are consuming larger and larger amounts of animal protein which leads to reduced calcium absorption by the body due to excreting it out of your urine.

Unlike some vitamins and minerals, calcium from supplements is very effective.

Dairy is linked with weight gain and obesity, heart disease and certain cancers. If you do the research I think you'll find that consuming dairy isn't worth it just for the calcium. You can get the calcium elsewhere.

Hitman-like you I am a lawyer and feel somewhat uneasy not citing everthing I state above. But, this is just a triathlon board and I am not going to take the time. Upon request, however, I will be glad to provide support for the above (and none of it is from PETA - while I don't consume animal products I do have leather seats on my car).

Hey, bigdogtwo,

You've said a mouthful!

I think we both agree that both calcium and Vitamin D are essential nutrients; and many, many individuals suffer adverse results because their diet is low in one or both. I've been doing quite a bit of reading on the subject the last couple of weeks, and am convinced of their importance.

That's why I'll drink my 3 glasses of milk a day, and am still looking into supplementation. As I previously noted, calcium absorption varies wildly, and many of the supplements have absorption rates of as little as 2% (calcium carbonate). Calcium citrate and calcium lactate have been mentioned as being more effective. I'd be interested in hearing your opinion on the most effective form of calcium supplement.

thehitman

“Always do right. This will gratify some people and astonish the rest.” Mark Twain
[/SIZE]

Triguy98's picture
Posts
2455
Member
1332 days
Triguy98 posted 2 years ago.

You can link jsut about anything to cancer from some studies everything from Sweet and Low to sunscreen has turned up cancer in some points. Dairy is linked to obesity? Hmm. Amusing that dairy products in other circles are considered fat burners. Dairy consumption is not a new thing among people. We have been drinking milk for thousands of years. Granted, not always the refined cows milk we primarily consume today, but dairy in some form or another has been consumed since agriculture was incepted.

Here's my observations: Long ride, no milk for breakfast= lower performance, usually crapping out about 1/2 way through. Only milk for breakfast= not good either. Gotta have balance.

Calcium and vitmain D deficiencies are not just present in the obese and lazy. As athletes, we are more dispositioned to osteoperosis. Especially with all the riding and swimming we do. I'm sure I wcould dig up support for any of the above statements as well, but I find it to be a waste of time. I have no doubt that there is a study out there linking sunlight to cancer... oh, wait...

Opinions are like @$$holes, everyone's got em. Some are just bigger than others.

Life is short. Play hard and get dirty doing it.

ggalvao's picture
Posts
290
Member
1064 days
ggalvao posted 2 years ago.

Blitz wrote:
I mean that some of them look like they have calcium deficiencies, and it's obvious when they smile. One can get plenty of calcium from the plant kingdom, but I prefer eating ice cream.

Blitz

Oh, got ya...

I usually drink between 500 ml to 1 l of milk everyday!

thehitman's picture
Posts
806
Member
1391 days
thehitman posted 2 years ago.

Triguy98 wrote:
You can link jsut about anything to cancer from some studies everything from Sweet and Low to sunscreen has turned up cancer in some points....

My favorite related study:
Several years ago, researchers found that all the items they tested were carcinogenic, except for popcorn and water! I don't think I'll be switching to that nutrition plan anytime soon, though. Of course, they probably didn't test wheat grass. :eek:

thehitman

“Always do right. This will gratify some people and astonish the rest.” Mark Twain
[/SIZE]