Quantcast

well...just got back from a couple local cycle shops and...

PGansz's picture
Posts
24
Member
1194 days
started by PGansz on July 6, 2005

the people at one shop only sell fuji and diamondback bikes and told me as a beginner it would be better to buy a cheaper bike (under like 800 bucks) so that i can get used to road racing, as i have never ridden a road bike...are fuji's any good?

the people at the next cycle shop sell a lot of trek stuff which i like, and told me that for triathlons and such i should be buying either the 1200 or 1500 models...which run between 850 and 1100 bucks...

well..which is it? i certainly would rather not spend a grand quite yet, but would it be worth it, especially for a beginner? i figured maybe he was just trying to make money off of me, a newcomer to the sport...

Triguy98's picture
Posts
2400
Member
1280 days
Triguy98 posted 3 years ago.

get nothing lower than a 105 equiped bike. 105 is pretty much the perfect starter bike group. Doesnt need to be upgraded right away like tiagra, but it also wont break the bank. A friend of mine has a 1500, nice bike.

Life is short. Play hard and get dirty doing it.

virturace's picture
Posts
95
Member
1549 days
virturace posted 3 years ago.

There's no right or wrong answer, but IMO, I say buy as much as you can afford. Not that a $700 bike is garbage or anything, but spending a little more and getting aero bars and lighter/better components, etc will make you more comfortable, probably faster, and give you more to work with once it comes time to upgrade.

I am new to cycling. I was looking at the Felt S32 (felt's entry-level tri bike) and got a great deal on the s25. It's full dura-ace, etc and when I want to upgrade, I pretty much will just need wheels and maybe carbon aero bars.

I can already tell that had I not bought more bike up front, I would have already (in just a few months) spent the difference dumping some of the inferior components, so it would have come out the wash anyway.

It just always seems easier to bite the bullet up front and then take your time on the next stuff.

Also, you could always get a professional measurement and then look for a used bike on craigslist.com or ebay.

VirtuRace | The Results You're Searching For.
www.virturace.com

pernfilman's picture
Posts
105
Member
1226 days
pernfilman posted 3 years ago.

step it up and buy what you like DO NOT TEST RIDE A BIKE OUT OF YOUR PRICE RANGE THOUGH!! Keep in mind with all your shopping that testing a bike within your budget is the only way to go. If you rode a 5000 dollar bike anything below that is more than likely going to feel as powerful and useful as the 85 dollar huffy you owned as a child. First bike i ever rode in a race was a lite speed. Two weeks later i spent 2500 on a bike that was the cheapest that i could do after test driving the Ferrari of bikes. The other bikes felt like crap compared to this beast i had borrowed. Pay a little more now and get a lot more later. Totally agree that at least go with a 105 Shimano set up at least. Good Luck

rb85cj7's picture
Posts
207
Member
1228 days
rb85cj7 posted 3 years ago.

A lot depends on aspirations. I thought i would just get into for fun and small rides, and now i do 50+ every weekend and i wish i would have bought a little better bike. Not that my Spezial Allez is bad, it is just that i bought the base model so if i want new shifters i have to get a new cassette and derailers. It is an all or nothing deal.

This actually works out better because if i could upgrade a little at a time, i would and my wife would divorce me. HAHA

craigvu's picture
Posts
23
Member
1242 days
craigvu posted 3 years ago.

My recent entry level bike decision was between the Trek 1500 and the Specialized Allez Elite...went with the Specialized because the Trek did not offer 105 rear deraileur standard on the 1500 series. Essentially the same bike, from what I understand, although I got a Gossamer compact crank and the Specialized racing seat with the bike...both of which get a lot of looks from the guys in my local group. But I agree with what these guys say, once you get into the sport you'll love it and will want the best bike you can have, so just be ready. Buy as much as you can, and then start saving again, cause you'll want a Cervelo or Quintana Roo before you know it...at least I do.

PGansz's picture
Posts
24
Member
1194 days
PGansz posted 3 years ago.

i can spend as much as i want...i just really don't know how worth it would be...i mean really, i have never ridden a road bike before so i'm almost positive i'll be happy with anything....

i think the trek 1200 seems about right...its got the 105 rear on it...i know the 1500 is a lot better, but i really can't see spending that much, i mean, with a huge need for a new set of forged irons...

christri25's picture
Posts
1339
Member
1344 days
christri25 posted 3 years ago.

go watch a triathlon and see what everyone is riding. thats a good place to start with. a bike shop is only going to sell you what they sell.

Chris

``It's not as if I'm going to sit around and be a fat slob,''
Lance Armstrong 2005

rb85cj7's picture
Posts
207
Member
1228 days
rb85cj7 posted 3 years ago.

Just make sure what you get is going to be easily upgradable.

PGansz wrote:

i think the trek 1200 seems about right...its got the 105 rear on it...i know the 1500 is a lot better, but i really can't see spending that much, i mean, with a huge need for a new set of forged irons...

Huge Need Aye. Good call.

swbkrun's picture
Posts
6
Member
1193 days
swbkrun posted 3 years ago.

pernfilman wrote:
step it up and buy what you like DO NOT TEST RIDE A BIKE OUT OF YOUR PRICE RANGE THOUGH!! Keep in mind with all your shopping that testing a bike within your budget is the only way to go. If you rode a 5000 dollar bike anything below that is more than likely going to feel as powerful and useful as the 85 dollar huffy you owned as a child. First bike i ever rode in a race was a lite speed. Two weeks later i spent 2500 on a bike that was the cheapest that i could do after test driving the Ferrari of bikes. The other bikes felt like crap compared to this beast i had borrowed. Pay a little more now and get a lot more later. Totally agree that at least go with a 105 Shimano set up at least. Good Luck

I couldn't agree more.. If money is no issue, go with what feels best...

[COLOR=Yellow][FONT=Arial Narrow]DREAM IT.
PLAN IT.
DO IT.
:cool:

Jeyradan's picture
Posts
129
Member
1244 days
Jeyradan posted 3 years ago.

If you can afford it, test-ride away. But be aware that, if you ride it and like it, you're going to want it. (This is how I ended up with both of my expensive bikes, tri and MTB. I should've known better, but at least I'm happy.) I know a lot of beginner triathletes that are starting out on the Cervelo Dual (more of a tri bike) or the Specialized Allez Comp or Elite (more of a road bike). Neither of those is exactly in the $800 range, though.

Official Hero: Tom Evans
1:12, 42.4, 3:46 1/2 IM

Noel's picture
Posts
255
Member
1255 days
Noel posted 3 years ago.

Hey man,

Trek is a good choice, there are so much good frames ou there. I have Trek bike, love it, LOOOOOVE IT!! Because the service is good, because there's a guy that works in the store that is a triathlete and couldn't care less what and WHERE you buy it. I asked him what HE would choose, if he wanted to put a bike toghether.
So now I have my Trek 5200 OCLV carbon bike with Ultegra parts. as my tri-bike and a normal road bike as my training bike. With 105 group it works well, good for training, just get a normal bike. And it's true... once I tested a OCLV CARBON, I was HOOKED, couldn't help it.
Orbea has good frames, Specialized has good frames, Trek has good frames, just get a 105 group, that'll do for now I guess, DON'T GET ONE THE CARBON BIKES UNLESS YOU WANT TO PAY FOR EM. God they're good... GOD THEY'RE expensive!

Noel.

www.noelbrand.blogspot.com
It ain't much, if it ain't Dutch!!

stone's picture
Posts
39
Member
1256 days
stone posted 3 years ago.

I am new tri's and new to road biking so I went on the shopping trip about 3 months ago. I ended up buying the Trek 1500 and I absolutely love it. It has 105 and fits me perfectly. As long as I don't let my butt hit anything Carbon Fiber, I know I will be happy with this bike until I am ready to buy a tri bike.

I test road everything that was equivalent to the Trek 1200 and 1500. I felt there was a huge difference between the 1200 and 1500 but not that much of difference when I jumped up to the 2100 (though it was nicer). I would recommend spending at least a grand. This will get you into a Trek 1500, Cannondale R600, Specialized Allez, etc. I have put a decent amount of miles on my 1500 and I have no urge to upgrade right now.

My opinion is spend about 1,000-1,200 (or more if you would like) and then test ride everything in that price range. I knew I liked the Trek the minute I took it around the parking lot.

Good luck and have fun

Mark

PrinceofClydes's picture
Posts
1707
Member
1489 days
PrinceofClydes posted 3 years ago.

The bike on which I finished my first Ironman triathlon came out of the city dump a month before the race - it was a Bianchi and had a nice triple-chainring up front which got me over the Richter Pass and up Yellow Lake.

This year I am riding a 20 year old Cramerotti with a Campagnolo groupo and friction shifters on the downtube. It cost me $300 second-hand.

and I bet Dave Zabriskie could beat the lot of you riding my bike!

heh.

Just make sure it fits.

PoC

"Pain doesn't last, chicks dig scars, glory is forever!"
- Shane Falco.

stone's picture
Posts
39
Member
1256 days
stone posted 3 years ago.

I bet any of those TdF guys could beet me with a tricycle.

Jeyradan's picture
Posts
129
Member
1244 days
Jeyradan posted 3 years ago.

Dave'd like a tricycle. Less chance of falling.
But seriously - he's my favorite.

Official Hero: Tom Evans
1:12, 42.4, 3:46 1/2 IM

thehitman's picture
Posts
806
Member
1339 days
thehitman posted 3 years ago.

PrinceofClydes wrote:
The bike on which I finished my first Ironman triathlon came out of the city dump a month before the race - it was a Bianchi and had a nice triple-chainring up front which got me over the Richter Pass and up Yellow Lake.

This year I am riding a 20 year old Cramerotti with a Campagnolo groupo and friction shifters on the downtube. It cost me $300 second-hand.

and I bet Dave Zabriskie could beat the lot of you riding my bike!

heh.

Just make sure it fits.

PoC

PoC -

I don't know - Rob was doing 25 - 27 mph on his old mountain bike (and he's upgraded to a Walmart Special). And Phil here, riding who knows what, did 10 miles in 25 minutes (24 mph) after a week or so of training.
http://www.trifuel.com/forums/showthread.php?t=2829

No wonder Lance is retiring after this Tour!

thehitman

thehitman

“Always do right. This will gratify some people and astonish the rest.” Mark Twain
[/SIZE]

rbreddin75's picture
Posts
461
Member
1262 days
rbreddin75 posted 3 years ago.

I just bought my first road bike (tri bike)

I have done one triathlon (a sprint) and looked seriously at everything from the cheapest road bike that fit me to the Cervelo Dual ($1,500). The bike I felt most comfortable on and that fit me the best was a 2004 cannondale Ironman 600 (see pic). It was on clearance and it fit me better than any of the other bikes.

NO MATTER WHAT YOU GET, MAKE SURE YOU'RE COMFORTABLE ON IT....

I know I will be...

[URL=http://rbreddin75.trifuel.net/][COLOR=DeepSkyBlue]PARADIGM : Triathlon
As Iron sharpens Iron, so one man sharpens another. proverbs 27:17
[url=http://www.northatlantamultisport.org]

tcrunner07's picture
Posts
350
Member
1369 days
tcrunner07 posted 3 years ago.

also check out locomotion bike shop locomotionbikes.com

i got my bike from there..Felt B2..and i love it...and they are great guys...they have great service on their bikes..they sell Giants, Cervelos and Felts out of their stock room. theyr have road bikes and tri bikes and can order alot of things

but iif they dont have what works for u..by all means...go somewhere else...

If you get a flat, and don't have a tube, Suck it up and run it in!!!

PrinceofClydes's picture
Posts
1707
Member
1489 days
PrinceofClydes posted 3 years ago.

thehitman wrote:

I don't know - Rob was doing 25 - 27 mph on his old mountain bike (and he's upgraded to a Walmart Special). And Phil here, riding who knows what, did 10 miles in 25 minutes (24 mph) after a week or so of training.

How were they doing 5 hours later?

:)

Poc

"Pain doesn't last, chicks dig scars, glory is forever!"
- Shane Falco.

gymrat6423's picture
Posts
4
Member
1389 days
gymrat6423 posted 3 years ago.

This is a subject that I think I can helpout with. About a year ago my wife and I got into triathlon thank's to an unexpected bonus check. We bought entry level Giant OCR 3's for $550. I was happy with the bike, as I did not think I would jump in to this as hard as I did. We started with 20 mile rides and did a sprint in Oct. I did not stop smiling for weeks!!!

Tomorrow we are doing a 50miler at 18- 20 and a four mile run of of the bike! Needless to say we are now upgrading (It has been a good year at the job!), It started out with a new pair of tri shoes, look pedels then came the aerobars (I never even used them in a race, before I bought my Cervelo last month! ). Same for my wife.

Then I realized I should just go buy the Damn Cervelo Dual ( I will love it once I get all of the kinks out of it) and get it over with, because I am now a TRI JUNKIE. The wife should she decide to do half iron's will be upgrading to somekind of CARBON hello Kestrel/Softride!!

Anyway the point of my story is this can be a VERY expensive hobby. and you do not know if you will like it or not as a begineer. There is a lot of discomfort in training and racing! The water is always cold (I live in Southen California and the Pacific is always COLD!), 20+ mph on the bike starts to hurt after 5+ minutes as you build your conditioning, and the run is a long mental fight that can have injuries to sideline you. But if this is your cup of tea, you will upgrade as your wallet allows for it!

So in summary start small and them make your upgrade choices as you get further into the sport. If you can find an inexpensive or even used bike and wetsuit to get you through the first race / season, then you can upgrade based on what you want by performance, not just want the Local Bike Shop has on sale on a given day. Train hard and race faster! !
Pete

PGansz's picture
Posts
24
Member
1194 days
PGansz posted 3 years ago.

thehitman wrote:
PoC -

I don't know - Rob was doing 25 - 27 mph on his old mountain bike (and he's upgraded to a Walmart Special). And Phil here, riding who knows what, did 10 miles in 25 minutes (24 mph) after a week or so of training.
http://www.trifuel.com/forums/showthread.php?t=2829

No wonder Lance is retiring after this Tour!

thehitman

yesterday i rode 10 miles in 21min and then 20 in 45min (even though i was going the same pace, this was according to a bike in a gym)...i mean really, what do i have to get these times down to in order to be a decent triathlete/cyclist?

PrinceofClydes's picture
Posts
1707
Member
1489 days
PrinceofClydes posted 3 years ago.

PGansz wrote:
yesterday i rode 10 miles in 21min and then 20 in 45min (even though i was going the same pace, this was according to a bike in a gym)...i mean really, what do i have to get these times down to in order to be a decent triathlete/cyclist?

It's contextual. Flojo held the world record for a hundred metres, but her best recorded time in a 10km is less than mine, and I don't consider myself a runner.

and Jan Kirsipu is an outstanding sprinter but has never finished a Tour de France. He can't get over the mountains in the allowed time.

Your bike times look great..

for a stationary bike in a gym. Go ride the IM course against a strong headwind and tell me how you feel about your performance.
It's all relative to the task.

PoC

"Pain doesn't last, chicks dig scars, glory is forever!"
- Shane Falco.

TurkTamer01's picture
Posts
3
Member
1191 days
TurkTamer01 posted 3 years ago.

the bike shops are only going to push the manufacturers that they sell. A main concern is a manufacturer warranty and the reliability of service. istarted with a cheap bike trying to upgrade as I went..BAD MOVE... componets are almost everything..after my learning xperince I got an Giant OCR elite..shimano ultegra all the way through. I don't do the bike much justice as of yet, but it's always there and screaming for more road..if you are passionate about it....I suggest you fork the money because it's going to effect your shifting and overall ride. Carbonfiber is a back saver and reduces weight as well. I looked at the ocr1 and the elite and I am glad i spend the 500 bucks. I stay on the bike alot longer...

Triguy98's picture
Posts
2400
Member
1280 days
Triguy98 posted 3 years ago.

TurkTamer01 wrote:
... componets are almost everything..after my learning xperince I got an Giant OCR elite..shimano ultegra all the way through...

It's not too common to find solid components on a shoddy frame, but it does happen... mostly online. Components make a difference for sure... the jump from Tiagra to Ultegra is def. gonna make a BIG dif. i your ride, BUT the frame is the fundamental thing that makes or breaks a bike. Trickle down technology is good stuff. Lower level bikes don't usually see it too much, but bike from ~$1k - $2k see a LOT of it. Frames that are a couple years from winning TDFs can be had for $2k from Trek, and I forget which on of QRs mid level bike sports the frame from last years model above it. $500 doesnt get you a good frame or good parts, but $1000 might get you a frame with ok parts, and the frame might be the same as the next model up...

Life is short. Play hard and get dirty doing it.

thehitman's picture
Posts
806
Member
1339 days
thehitman posted 3 years ago.

PGansz: - "yesterday i rode 10 miles in 21min and then 20 in 45min (even though i was going the same pace, this was according to a bike in a gym)...i mean really, what do i have to get these times down to in order to be a decent triathlete/cyclist?"

Step 1 - If your trainer has a 0 to 10 scale for resistance; adjust it to above 0 in the future.
Step 2 - Get on a real bike and do 10 miles on a flat surface.
Step 3 - Let us know how you did, and maybe you'll get some meaningful advise.

thehitman

thehitman

“Always do right. This will gratify some people and astonish the rest.” Mark Twain
[/SIZE]

PGansz's picture
Posts
24
Member
1194 days
PGansz posted 3 years ago.

as my question imposed, all i wanted to know was what competitive times are in triathlons for cycling and what not so i know for future reference...obviously i would shoot below those times on a indoor bike to make up for wind resistence and what not...

perhaps you shouldn't be so negative...every post by you so far has done nothing but poke fun at me...since this site and every other forum is designed for learning i'd figure the biggest posters would be the most positive and meaningful, guess you really do learn something new everyday...

for your info, the resistence was on 6 out of 12, turning 90 revs per minute, with my heart rate constant at about 140-150, and small fluctuations in elevation...what more do you want in two weeks? i don't want to see your name in my posts if all you're going to do is be an ass about things...which is funny since your in your 50's you'd think you might have learned a lot about approaching people for the first time, thank god everyone else has been nice so far...

i'm not prepared to spend 1000 bucks on a bike right now...and since i attend college and live off campus i use my car to get to school, hence i don't have a bike up here, and the last bike i owned was a 100 dollar piece of **** from sports authority that corroded 5 years ago....so unless someone gives me one, i don't have one...

please be constructive or just don't post...i mean honestly, geeze man....

bluebirdbiker's picture
Posts
2861
Member
1262 days
bluebirdbiker posted 3 years ago.

Hey PGansz, I haven't said anything yet but have been reading the posts. The best way I think that one could answer your question is to tell you to check the previous years stats for the race in your age category (i.e., times of the first second etc. placers). What is competative is different for each course. It's hard to say, each course is different, some hilly and some flat.

So check previous years times in the your age category, try the course to see where you are at. Then, train to get where you want to be.

Hope this helps.
BBB

BBB
There are no excuses - so don't look for them. As a product of your own choices, you directly determine your life outcomes.
Don't think, just do.
My Blog

PrinceofClydes's picture
Posts
1707
Member
1489 days
PrinceofClydes posted 3 years ago.

PGansz wrote:
perhaps you shouldn't be so negative...every post by you so far has done nothing but poke fun at me...

...which is funny since your in your 50's you'd think you might have learned a lot about approaching people for the first time, thank god everyone else has been nice so far...

please be constructive or just don't post...i mean honestly, geeze man....

Phil, Phil, Phil, don't be so sensitive now.. :)

Don't you know us old fogies can't help poking a little fun at the rookies?

Hitman can be ascerbic now and then, but your post about doing a "10 mile ride in 21 minutes.." on an indoor trainer and sounding all excited about it, was just too tempting a bubble not to burst. Let's say it was a wee bit naive and you brought it on yourself.

About times: as BBBiker has pointed out above, you can check a race site - there are lots of them - and see what the current times are for your age group and race distance are.

About the bike, as I pointed out you can race on anything really. I did. No need to spend a lot of money. Buy second hand if you're a poor student. Been there, know what it's like. I already told you I did IM on a bike that came out of the city dump, and my "upgrade" for this year's race only cost $300 bucks.

Hitman's advice: Go ride a real bike down a real road and let us know how you do is appropriate I think. In fact I said much the same thing to you in my post a little bit above his.
"Go ride the IM course against a strong headwind and tell me how you feel about your performance. " - PoC

A little dose of reality, now and then, is a good thing, I think.

PoC
and we really will offer you good advice when you need it..
(as long as you don't pout!)
:)

"Pain doesn't last, chicks dig scars, glory is forever!"
- Shane Falco.

PGansz's picture
Posts
24
Member
1194 days
PGansz posted 3 years ago.

in what way was i being naive...thats the exact reason i stated it was on an indoor bike, so you guys had a clue of where i'm at after a few weeks...any idiot on the planet knows riding in real life will be slower, which is why i stated said conditions...

looking up times is a good idea, thanks....

thehitman's picture
Posts
806
Member
1339 days
thehitman posted 3 years ago.

PGansz said:
[I]"any idiot on the planet knows riding in real life will be slower, which is why i stated said conditions..."

I don't know that Phil. And to the extent that you believe it, you're wrong.
If you doubt it, set your resistance at 12 and take a 15 minute ride at 90 rpm.

But if you want to provide us with some useful information, set the resistance on your trainer so that you're doing 90 rpms and have a heart rate of at least 180 for 15 minutes; then get back to us. My heart rate averaged 175 for my last time-trial, and yours (theoretically) should be much higher.

And there's no reason you can't do like thousands of others and start out on a $25 garage sale ten-speed.

thehitman

thehitman

“Always do right. This will gratify some people and astonish the rest.” Mark Twain
[/SIZE]

PGansz's picture
Posts
24
Member
1194 days
PGansz posted 3 years ago.

so set it to something i have a heart rate of 180...what type of info should i get back to you with?

my heart rate was ~145 for 53 minutes yesterday on a 20 mile ride...legs were a little sore from the day before...

i'm having a hard time pushing my heart rate above 180...approaching that limit is easy, but getting over it is something i'm still working on...the highest i've seen so far is 183 for a split second...

thehitman's picture
Posts
806
Member
1339 days
thehitman posted 3 years ago.

Phil -

For future reference, you didn't go on a 20 mile ride. You rode an exercise bike. And you never went 10 miles in 21 minutes.

so set it to something i have a heart rate of 180...what type of info should i get back to you with? PGansz

I used 180 as the target heart rate based on the formula 220 minus age times 90 percent. The fact that you can't come anywhere close to completing that test (at any resistance) indicates to me that your aerobic conditionig needs lots of work. What's the maximum heart rate you can sustain for 15 minutes? Ride at a resistance that produces that heart rate for 15 minutes, and tell us 1) your avg. heart rate, 2) the resistance, and 3) the "mileage."

Its much easier way to gauge where you're at, if you use an actual time trial on a bike (any bike). On a flat surface, ride 3 miles, attempting to cover the maximum distance. Rest, then do it again. Record your time (avg speed), and preferrably, your maximum and avg. heart rates. Now you have some really useful information.

thehitman

thehitman

“Always do right. This will gratify some people and astonish the rest.” Mark Twain
[/SIZE]

PGansz's picture
Posts
24
Member
1194 days
PGansz posted 3 years ago.

who ever said i can't complete a test? i said i haven't seen my heart rate past 183, which means one thing, i didn't push hard enough...you're drawing way too many conclusions from this...

what are you talking about with zero resistance stuff?

if there were a place close by and readily accessible to right i would....i'll try and find one and get some info to you quickly hitman...

thehitman's picture
Posts
806
Member
1339 days
thehitman posted 3 years ago.

who ever said i can't complete a test? ...... if there were a place close by and readily accessible to right i would....i'll try and find one and get some info to you quickly hitman... PGansz

Let's see. I've proposed a couple of ways to test yourself on your stationary bike, and a couple of road tests. PoC's suggested that you test yourself on the road. Its not that you can't complete a test, its that you haven't.

I'm not sure what "place" you need to go to. Where's the staitionary bike now; and isn't there a road where you live?

thehitman

thehitman

“Always do right. This will gratify some people and astonish the rest.” Mark Twain
[/SIZE]