Quantcast

Good Protein???

tri1on's picture
Posts
105
Member
1328 days
started by tri1on on June 5, 2005

First of all what makes a source of protein good vs. bad...is it merely the fat content of the meat? Would wild game such as venison and waterfowl be considered good protein...it is very lean and much better than the traditional red meats.

I hunt and eat alot of vension and i can say from experience that is is little to no fat within the muscles unlike beef and other domestic animals.

christri25's picture
Posts
1335
Member
1309 days
christri25 posted 3 years ago.

become a vegitarian !! LOL lots of good protein available.

Chris

``It's not as if I'm going to sit around and be a fat slob,''
Lance Armstrong 2005

trithis04's picture
Posts
414
Member
1290 days
trithis04 posted 3 years ago.

tri1on,

Let me try and recall this info. quickly. Just had all this stuff in a human body class last semester.

As far as protein goes, there is no good or bad. It all becomes amino acids or polypeptides away. But it is always a good idea to eat the leaner choice to obtain it. For example, grilled boneless skinless chicken breast over deep fat fried burger. So, if your hunting a lean source of protein then your good to go.

Just thought I mention, don' t let the marketing ploys of these nutrition companies fool you. There is no difference in the end result between protein sources. The major difference here: How much you spend to get it! I suppose protein shakes etc. are ok, if you don't get enough in your diet from other sources. But most people do. They just throw their money away on that crap!

[FONT=Impact]-Jason
"Fatigue will make cowards of us all!"

tri1on's picture
Posts
105
Member
1328 days
tri1on posted 3 years ago.

Christri-
Ive heard the opposite...that vegetarians need to be careful and try to get different sources of protein from their diet and that the vegetatian diet usually relies on only the legumes for protein....besides the milk and egg products. im curious...i love veggies but dont think I will ever give up meat.

can i ask a personal ? why do you choose the vegetarion diet? Again....just curious

T-Baby's picture
Posts
2
Member
1189 days
T-Baby posted 3 years ago.

Next time you are shopping around for protein powder or supplements, please closely look at the price of protein per LB, protein quality, and protein per serving, because a lot of you guys are over looking this and getting ripped off, plain and simple.

Take a look at TrueProtein.com You can even get a better price with this discount code : RBN727 which can be typed in when you're ordering.

Seriously, this is the best protein I've ever had. It blew away my former choice of ON Whey. The price and quality will really impress. Give it a look.

tri1on's picture
Posts
105
Member
1328 days
tri1on posted 3 years ago.

trithis-

I agree one hundred percent. But now that you brought to light the amino acid problem, and i guess that is what i meant to say to christri is that there are some essential, and non-essential AA (amino-acids) and you get all of them from meat, but you dont get all of them from vegetables...am I right on this????? Not that you cant get then from vegetables(???) but you have to eat a wide variety of them?

PaulVball's picture
Posts
13
Member
1200 days
PaulVball posted 3 years ago.

You are correct. There are nine essential amino acids and they cannot all be gotten from a vegetarian diet. You need other souces (non meat is fine) such as suuplements, soy or whey etc. Figure out which works best for you. Personally soy protein isolate has the best effect on me. Good luck!

tcrunner07's picture
Posts
350
Member
1334 days
tcrunner07 posted 3 years ago.

so does anyone buy the Whey Protein from GNC...currently i dont take any supplements..i thnk i get enough protein from what i eat and i thnk i am geting what i am suppose to be geting along the lines of nutrients by the food i eat...is there anythng that i am probably missing that is usually only taken in by a supplement that i should look into?

If you get a flat, and don't have a tube, Suck it up and run it in!!!

walchka's picture
Posts
61
Member
1278 days
walchka posted 3 years ago.

I use whey protein from Vitamin World. I get most of my protein from the foods that I eat, but I use the powder in my recovery drinks. I don't know about the protein from GNC, but I've been happy with the stuff from VW.

RV's picture
Posts
3337
Member
1326 days
RV posted 3 years ago.

I use the GNC whey protein - also mostly for recovery drinks. I used some other proteins (ON) but this seems to mix much easier than the others. Seems like an okay deal - usually there is free shipping or the second is 50% off etc... Typical internet deals.

RV

It takes a long time to get good. - Scott Molina
Slow is smooth; smooth is fast. - Rich Strauss

T-Baby's picture
Posts
2
Member
1189 days
T-Baby posted 3 years ago.

Hey guys,

Seriously check out my post above about True Protein and the discount code I provided.

The GNC brands are going to kill you with their prices. True Protein has excellent prices and the quality is also better than your big company GNC brands. Just head over to the site and browse. If you decide to buy, you have a discount code to get 5% off their already great prices. You won't be disappointed. :cool:

JoseM's picture
Posts
159
Member
1230 days
JoseM posted 3 years ago.

I've gone to GNC to ask about the whey products before and two different people (at two different GNC stores) told me that the American Whey was the best they carried (most refined and most protein per pound of powder). I bought my first three 3-pound plastic jars from GNC and went online and found a few stores that sold them a good bit cheaper. I just bought two more jars online and saved $15.00/jar including the shipping for online and the tax for buying locally. I ended up paying $42 for both jars plus $5.95 shipping. It should get here today or tomorrow. Check online.

So....what you're saying is....benching 1.5 times your body weight 10+ times is NOT good for triathletes?! OOOOOH! :eek: :D

thehitman's picture
Posts
806
Member
1304 days
thehitman posted 3 years ago.

If you want a good, cheap protein, then buy a gallon of fat-free milk. Drink 3 glasses a day, just like your mom told you. Its got carbs, too.

thehitman

thehitman

“Always do right. This will gratify some people and astonish the rest.” Mark Twain
[/SIZE]

JamieM's picture
Posts
833
Member
1285 days
JamieM posted 3 years ago.

I use the GNC protein as well (and I've tried the Vitamin World stuff, I'll stick with GNC thanks) mostly for recovery drinks and have been happy with the results.

KenMierke's picture
Posts
183
Member
1217 days
KenMierke posted 3 years ago.

The post above is a pretty good suggestion. Any animal product will have protein that can be assimilated at least 90%. Egg whites are the best at 96%. More expensive protein supplements only make more expensive urine. There is nothing better about the protein in supplements except convenience ... which can be an important factor. Ken

Ken Mierke Ken@Fitness-Concepts.com
Fitness Concepts Fitness-Concepts.com
Author, The Triathlete's Guide to Run Training
www.EvolutionRunning.com

JoseM's picture
Posts
159
Member
1230 days
JoseM posted 3 years ago.

KenMierke wrote:
The post above is a pretty good suggestion. Any animal product will have protein that can be assimilated at least 90%. Egg whites are the best at 96%. More expensive protein supplements only make more expensive urine. There is nothing better about the protein in supplements except convenience ... which can be an important factor. Ken

While I agree that there is nothing better about the protein in supplements over the protein from food....you'll be intaking other stuff with food that you don't necessarily need/want. The supplement is there to help your meals by focusing on what you need...hence the name "supplement".

So....what you're saying is....benching 1.5 times your body weight 10+ times is NOT good for triathletes?! OOOOOH! :eek: :D

thehitman's picture
Posts
806
Member
1304 days
thehitman posted 3 years ago.

Jose -

I guess the question, then, is why you think you need protein supplementation over and above what a healthy diet can provide.

thehitman

thehitman

“Always do right. This will gratify some people and astonish the rest.” Mark Twain
[/SIZE]

PaulVball's picture
Posts
13
Member
1200 days
PaulVball posted 3 years ago.

In answer to the above, it has been my experience with my clients that protein (especially in recovery drinks) is assimilated by the body quicker than the protein in solid foods. After a hard workout / race (or in my case, tournament) I use JogMate Protein (a pudding gel type supplement that actually tastes good) for quick recovery and a soy protein isolate powder with fiber for added recovery plus meal replacement during the week. I would not use these drinks or gels as a muscle builder per se, just as an added supplement for recovery

There is absolutely no substituting a good high protein diet (Omega 3 rich also) but not everyone can get the benefits from just that. Plus right after a workout/race most people are not looking to sit and have a meal.

JoseM's picture
Posts
159
Member
1230 days
JoseM posted 3 years ago.

thehitman wrote:
Jose -

I guess the question, then, is why you think you need protein supplementation over and above what a healthy diet can provide.

thehitman

I was told (didn't do research so I took it at face value) that after workouts, you have ~ 30 minutes to get protein back into your body after a workout for optimal results (this was mainly referring to lifting weights but I transferred it over to my other workouts as well). And as PaulV stated, a supplement is assimilated into your body much quicker than say...a boiled egg (also as a side note....I know after I finish a workout, a protein drink is MUCH more satisfying than sucking down a boiled egg ;) )

So....what you're saying is....benching 1.5 times your body weight 10+ times is NOT good for triathletes?! OOOOOH! :eek: :D

thehitman's picture
Posts
806
Member
1304 days
thehitman posted 3 years ago.

Jose and Paul -

Now I understand. You guys are talking bodybuilding/weight-lifting talk. I've lifted weights since the 1970s, and been on more than one high-protein diet. Been there. Done that. Bad idea. Just my opinion.

Want extra protein after a work-out, have a chocolate milkshake. Lots of protein and carbs.

thehitman

thehitman

“Always do right. This will gratify some people and astonish the rest.” Mark Twain
[/SIZE]

PaulVball's picture
Posts
13
Member
1200 days
PaulVball posted 3 years ago.

Actually, I am not talking about lifting weights at all. I am talking more from competitions in beach volleyball tournaments which I am sure are less taxing on your body than triathlons are. Yeah you could have a chocolate milkshake, but why would you want to? (other than TASTES GOOD :) Carbs in that are non nutritional (ok you get some calcium and protein, but not a big value) and hell with the sugar crash also.

I would rather replenish with good protein versus bad. And yeah, the window of 30 minutes is a good rule of thumb, but some of us can go a couple hours before needed the protein boost.

Personally I would never recommend a high protein diet to anyone and that's not what I am trying to do. Above in my last post, what I meant was there is no subsituting a high protein diet with supplements. I would rather see a 40-30-30 diet to any athlete I work with. BUT the poster wanted to know about good vs bad protein.

thehitman's picture
Posts
806
Member
1304 days
thehitman posted 3 years ago.

Paul -

Are we talking good carb-bad carb now? And a 40-30-30 diet, too?

And if we're talking about good protein, I'll return to my recommendation that the poster drink 3 glasses of milk a day.

thehitman

thehitman

“Always do right. This will gratify some people and astonish the rest.” Mark Twain
[/SIZE]

JoseM's picture
Posts
159
Member
1230 days
JoseM posted 3 years ago.

JoseM wrote:
I've gone to GNC to ask about the whey products before and two different people (at two different GNC stores) told me that the American Whey was the best they carried (most refined and most protein per pound of powder). I bought my first three 3-pound plastic jars from GNC and went online and found a few stores that sold them a good bit cheaper. I just bought two more jars online and saved $15.00/jar including the shipping for online and the tax for buying locally. I ended up paying $42 for both jars plus $5.95 shipping. It should get here today or tomorrow. Check online.

Alright, I just received the order I placed (placed it on Sunday, received it on Wednesday). I wanted to wait until I received it before I gave the company's name (didn't want to give a name of a company until it proved itself to me;)).... Vigorous Living . This is one of the brands that GNC carries (but not all GNC's, go figure) and I've tried 5 flavors so far....ranking from 1-5 (1 being worst) I'd say...

Chocholate - 5
Vanilla - 5
Berry - 3
Orange - 2
Banana - 2

Vanilla and Chocholate were way above the others...Berry was different, kinda nice...orange was alright but it didn't dissolve nearly as well as the other 4....Banana is just kinda weird, I mixed banana and chocholate (half and half) and will have it after my workout today at lunch....that should be pretty good (chocholate is a bit strong and banana is kinda weak). Anyway, this place was the cheapest I found and if you ordered more than $50, you get some sort of coupon...also they gave me a free sample of another sort of protein powder that I never heard of in my order. So this is my source from now on (unless I get in a pinch and have to go back to GNC). And no...I'm not affiliated at all with the place :p

So....what you're saying is....benching 1.5 times your body weight 10+ times is NOT good for triathletes?! OOOOOH! :eek: :D

pernfilman's picture
Posts
105
Member
1191 days
pernfilman posted 3 years ago.

I recommend milk I knock out 3 gallons a week. My bone structure is practically steel like superman beacuse of it. Milk it does a body good.

8701nicole's picture
Posts
21
Member
1274 days
8701nicole posted 3 years ago.

I heard of the "get the protien quick" after a workout thing as well. But the last thing my stomach wants is a big meal after a workout. So I just stick w/ the shakes or a smoothie. Then after an hour or so, I'll eat a meal. Hope that's ok. Seems to be working ok for know.

Nicole

8701Nicole :cool:

kddubb's picture
Posts
40
Member
1235 days
kddubb posted 3 years ago.

tri1on wrote:
Christri-
Ive heard the opposite...that vegetarians need to be careful and try to get different sources of protein from their diet and that the vegetatian diet usually relies on only the legumes for protein....besides the milk and egg products. im curious...i love veggies but dont think I will ever give up meat.

can i ask a personal ? why do you choose the vegetarion diet? Again....just curious

Since I don't think you ever got your answer to this I thought I would answer it as well as try to stop some of the misinformation about vegetarian protein.

First, you can get get more than enough complete protein from a vegetarian diet. However, usually your body needs to process incomplete proteins into complete proteins from a vegetarian diet (exceptions listed below). All you need to do is eat a wide variaty of vegetables, grains, and legumes (I don't have my veg. cookbook to remember the specific combinations that your body can synthesize) each day which becomes rather easy when you aren't filling up on meat or processed foods.

You can also directly intake complete proteins from soy products and fresh sprouts (I have a jar ready to harvest for lunch today). Sprouts are the perfect food. :)

If you are vegetarian and not vegan (no animal products whatsoever), you can get complete protein from milk products (milk, yogurt, cheese, etc.) and eggs. I love cheese and eat it regularly.

I eat about 90% vegetarian meals and 10% meals that include some form of meat. When I do eat meat I try to eat small portions and usually fish or chicken if possible. I would eat all vegetarian, but I enjoy hanging out for meals with friends and family that don't share my convictions.

There are many reasons for becoming vegetarian:

1) Eating nutrient dense foods. Vegetables and whole grains are packed with vitamins, minerals, enzymes and other nutrients compared to their caloric density. That means you are getting many more nutrients eating a 2,000 calorie vegetarian diet than you would a 2,000 calorie diet including meat. (And although I still supplement, they aren't the total answer to nutritional deficiency either) Eating more nutriously helps your body work optimally.
2) I forget the specific statistic, but it takes an immense amount of food to raise animals to be sold as meat. That means expensive.
3) In order to make meat less expensive, feed lot practices are horrible. So the meat you get is much less quality and nutrious than it was 50 or even 20 years ago. (When I do buy meat, I buy from Ranch Foods Direct, a company that buys local, non-hormonalized, free-range meat).
4) There are lots of environmental ramifications of raising all of the cattle, chickens, etc. to support a meat diet for everyone.

That's just for starters, but enough for this post. I eat vegetarian because I work too hard to be healthy and at peak performance. Some will argue with me about this, but I believe you won't be performing at your peak when eating standard American diet amounts of meat. Studies show (again I don't have the statistic in front of me) that most Americans eat at leat 4 times the amount of protein they need in a day.

I used to think I could NEVER give up meat (I was born and bred a meat 'n potatoes boy). Over the past year and half I've gradually given it up. I think most of our attachment to meat is psychological instead of physiological. Now, that I don't eat it (very much), I don't miss it and when I do eat it, my body doesn't like it (usually fish is OK in my system though). I also feel much better, stronger and healthier than ever by far and my training times prove it. I'll never go back to eating meat regularly.

Don't knock it until you try it...but I would try gradual transitions like I did (6 months to a year of eating less and less meat). If you drop it cold turkey (no pun intended), you'll have lots of cravings and most likely not succeed in the transition. Another way to help break the cravings more quickly is to do a juice fast. This helps your body reset itself (of course you usually have to go through 3-5 days of INTENSE cravings for food in general) and help minimize cravings.

Anyway, I'm starting to go off on tangents so that's enough for now.

kddubb

tonedef131's picture
Posts
5
Member
1172 days
tonedef131 posted 3 years ago.

pernfilman wrote:
I recommend milk I knock out 3 gallons a week. My bone structure is practically steel like superman beacuse of it. Milk it does a body good.
Have fun passing those stones ;)

I agree that a high protien diet consisting of mostly supplemented protien does not work. I have tried that and the results were mediocre at best. I do however like to have a protien shake after my workout before I jump in the shower. It seems to help my stomach prepare itself for a meal and aid in muscle recovery. I really like Chicago Nutritions Impact Protien. The flavor is great and it is a blend of a lot of different protiens for a controled release. The only other time that I will use a protien supplement is when I am in a hurry in the mornings and make a smoothie, I will usually thow a bit in there...it seems to help satiate.