Bike gear, which make is the best?
I love Camp-granola, used to have a Specialized that was all campy (lost it in the divorce). It's G-R-E-A-T stuff but way to expensive for me now. I have Shimano now, a combo platter of Dura ace and Ultegra with some Zero-G brakes thrown in. Shimano is easy to find, and it's easy to find deals on it. Campy, at least around here, easy to get , but the $$$!
"If e wishes to sweem in dangerous waters, oo are we to deny im?
-Chef Skinner
http://antonspath.blogspot.com
Okay I understood about half of that.........that's good. tell me what you want in Campy I will do a price check for you.
Problem I have is I can both but if I fork out, I actually don't know enough to know what I am getting
Dreams are the stars which charter the course of our lives. Happy the one who follows their dreams
I love Camp-granola, used to have a Specialized that was all campy (lost it in the divorce). It's G-R-E-A-T stuff but way to expensive for me now. I have Shimano now, a combo platter of Dura ace and Ultegra with some Zero-G brakes thrown in. Shimano is easy to find, and it's easy to find deals on it. Campy, at least around here, easy to get , but the $$$!
Let me decipher: "All campy" means Campy from front derailleur to rear. "Way too expensive" means things like $400 rear derailleurs and $800 cranksets. A "combo platters" (like fried shrimp and maybe catfish) means a selection of DA and Ultegra, like DA STIs (I'm doing it too now) and Ultegra cranks, or maybe Ultegra STIs and DA rear derailluers. It's a mix and match of parts. And Zero-G brakes are lustworthy superlight Ciamillos (which I must have, paired with Jawires and Nokons . . . dammit!). "Easy to find" means any LBS has Shimano parts in stock. Many (most?) LBSs don't keep too Super Record 11 parts in stock. It ties up a lot of cash to keep $3,000 groupos sitting around. Campy is "easy to get" if you ride from a large LBS, but typically LBSs are proud of their Campy.
Please don't turn TriFuel into a war of "Which is better? Campy vs Shimano?" And I do mean "versus". Fortunately very few tri bikes come with Campy because . . . I have no idea. It seems Shimano cornered the bar-end shifter market. Regardless, comparable groups will give comparable performance. Leave it at that and walk away and no one gets hurt. (Note that I didn't even committ in writing which groups are comparable. Even doing that could start a flame war at some sites so I won't even try to align groups.)
The difference is purely a function of what you came into this sport riding, what your aesthetics are (Campy uses carbon extensively, Shimano is all aluminum), mixed with a heavy dose of romance and nostalgia. When I think of Campy, I think of the Dolomites, the Amalfi coast, Isabella Rossellini, and Tuscan wines. When I think of Shimano, I think of faceless technologies traded on the Nikkei, dowtown Tokyo, and fishing reels. They both do the same thing. They both cost more or less the same. My $.02 is whichever you buy, go with the highest level you can afford.
Hmm I am pretty sure my shimanos are carbon.....
Certainly not into starting any type of war, Just looking to find what you folks use and why. I got the what you use, and I got cost being a major factor... but surely there is more? All opinions are welcome as long as they come with respect :-)
Dreams are the stars which charter the course of our lives. Happy the one who follows their dreams
campy has a whole range, from relatively inexpensive to super record. i think that most people's consensus is that it is a matter of feel (for road bikes, different shaped brifters, different shifting throws and ranges), rather than quality. that being said, i have campy shifters and derailleurs, zipp crank, and zero-g brakes on my tri bike, and all campy record on my road bike. my mtb has a shimano fd (mostly sram). that being said, i really don't like to ride shimano, for reasons similar to trisooner.
on my TT bike, I have full Sram Red, and i love it. Its lighter than any other component line, and it still has great shifting. I love the Sram red bar-end shifters, especially compared to the ugly old-looking Shimano tt shifters. On my road bike i have full DA 7900, which shifts smoother than SRam, and i especially like the new little changes that have come from the change of 7800 to 7900. Still, nothing shifts smoother than Campy super record, but it does cost a fortune.
"You can never be too rich or too skinny."
-My doctor










I read a lot about shimano or Campagnolo gears, shifters derailers, pedals, etc; They appear to be the two best marques in Europe. However while they are truly good quality, if you buy the cheaper versions, they are as bad as anything else.
I was wondering in the Vast halls of cycle experience here, which models and makes are on your bikes and why?
Dreams are the stars which charter the course of our lives. Happy the one who follows their dreams