Quantcast

Bikes recommendations for the overweight beginner

E_Diesel's picture
Posts
2
Member
198 days
started by E_Diesel on May 11, 2009

Hi all-

Just wondering if anyone out there has any bike recommendations for an overweight beginner. I've tried a couple bikes out and did not feel comfortable with the support. I was wondering if anyone had any suggestions.

tri-ac's picture
Posts
2766
Member
1445 days
tri-ac posted 27 weeks ago.

you will find that if you ride regularly for longer than a couple of months, you will wish you started with something "decent." this is that level of "decent:"

my typical advice to a beginner is get a road bike with shimano 105 components or equal. this will be $1000-1500 with shoes and pedals. this setup may be more advanced than you are thinking about, but it is an investment in "decent" equipment.

there are a couple of folks on here who have lost a bunch of weight...i'll leave it to them to help on the overweight part of things

TriSooner's picture
Posts
2255
Member
703 days
TriSooner posted 27 weeks ago.

1) How overweight are we talking? Some components have sprigthly suggested weight limits, like 200lbs for Alpha and Reynolds carbon forks, and 180lbs for ti-spindled Speedplay. And 2) what have you tried?

dscf23's picture
Posts
138
Member
393 days
dscf23 posted 27 weeks ago.

You should tell us how overweight you are. You might change the tires from 23 to 25-28 and feel a lot better.

Daniel

paganopj's picture
Posts
283
Member
357 days
paganopj posted 27 weeks ago.

My suggestion (not knowing your weight) would be a decent mountain bike to start with. Many sprint races even have entries for fat tire bikes (mountain bikes). When ready, you can buy "street slicks" tires for your bike too. Once you decide to move to a road bike, you'll have a spare as well as something you can take off road.

I'd suggest if you go for a road bike, you get some tires that will accept high tire pressure (at least 140lbs) Good luck!

Just keep spinning....spinning, spinning....uh, do I know you?
The Losing Journey Flickr Cycling Log

orangedog's picture
Posts
186
Member
456 days
orangedog posted 27 weeks ago.

paganopj wrote:
My suggestion (not knowing your weight) would be a decent mountain bike to start with. Many sprint races even have entries for fat tire bikes (mountain bikes). When ready, you can buy "street slicks" tires for your bike too. Once you decide to move to a road bike, you'll have a spare as well as something you can take off road.

I'd suggest if you go for a road bike, you get some tires that will accept high tire pressure (at least 140lbs) Good luck!

+1... plus, pushing around a 35lb mountain bike is a workout in itself. another plus, you can work your way over to the dark side of xterra.

www.theorangedog.net
skills>> spirits>> speed>>

the staring man's picture
Posts
25
Member
257 days
the staring man posted 27 weeks ago.

E,
How much weight are we discussing? I'll give you my story and hope this provides you a good frame of reference.
I started at 5 foot 7 inches and 205 pounds on January 1, 2009. I purchased at Giant Defy for $1,300 with Shimano 105 components. I'm still 5'7" but now 193 as of today.
Another option to consider is Spinning classes at your local gym. I still participate 2 -3 times a week. The instructors are awesome, they kick my butt everytime and I love it. Lots of sweat, power, and loud music. Its not quite the club but you get the idea.

prendergi's picture
Posts
379
Member
220 days
prendergi posted 27 weeks ago.

You could always try a hybrid. My hubby bought a Specialized hybrid. My husband is in the same boat. He wants to lose more weight before investing in a road bike. My hubby is about 6 foot, 6 foot 1 and 275.

"The pain of discipline is far less than the pain of regret" - Sarah Bombell

E_Diesel's picture
Posts
2
Member
198 days
E_Diesel posted 27 weeks ago.

I am 5'10", 303lbs with my ideal weight being in the neighborhood of 215-220. I am currently preparing for a tri in Oct. and wanted to avoid buying a cruiser if possible. I want to purchase a bike that I can compete with. Can you really compete in a tri on a hybrid? My apologizes if this seems like a naive question- just getting into the sport and trying to learn as much as possible.

prendergi's picture
Posts
379
Member
220 days
prendergi posted 27 weeks ago.

I was in my first tri last month. I saw everything from a 10 year old rusting mountain bike to the top of the line tri bike (with it's $2000 wheels). I would say yes, you can race on a hybrid.

"The pain of discipline is far less than the pain of regret" - Sarah Bombell

orangedog's picture
Posts
186
Member
456 days
orangedog posted 27 weeks ago.

I started at 315, and at the time, my opinion was that the type of bike didn't matter (and I still hold to that opinion). Buy the cheapest bike you can get away with - a beat up second hand craigslist mountain bike. Anticipate that if you use the bike, you will destroy it.

The flip side is that if you use it, you will likely lose weight. Because you'll have lost weight, you'll actually be in a position to take advantage of a higher quality bike, and your bike fit may change. So, you'll be ready to pull the trigger on a higher end bike, one that is actually good for competing.

This allows you to avoid a high cash outlay now, learn about what you like/don't like in a bike, familiarize yourself with technique (balance, braking, etc.), and get a higher quality bike when you'll actually be able to notice and take advantage of the higher quality. It will also give you time to see what other people use, demo other bikes at events, etc. All around a win-win, I figure.

Just my $0.02.

www.theorangedog.net
skills>> spirits>> speed>>

firegirl's picture
Posts
58
Member
1392 days
firegirl posted 26 weeks ago.

+1 to orangedog. i compete on a crappy road bike that i bought when i started tri. i recently decided to start commuting, so i bought a mountain bike off craigslist (mostly so if it got stolen while i was at work i wouldn't be without my road bike.) i threw some conti town and country's on it and while it's no road bike, i can get some decent speed on asphalt and i don't have to worry about eating it when i turn a corner.

i'm really glad i didn't shell out major bucks when i got started. my position and preferences have changed a ton since i started, and i still consider myself a total novice. now when i finally get to buy my sweet ride (read: convince my husband to let me :-)) i will know what i want.

just a thought.
cheers.

ps. i'm not particularly slow on the bike, and i've definitely been passed by 12year olds on mountain bikes. great for the self esteem...

ChunkyB's picture
Posts
1037
Member
768 days
ChunkyB posted 26 weeks ago.

In my experience, the frame isn't really the issue with being overweight (unless you're thinking of a full carbon frame). It's the wheels that really matter. I don't know enough about wheels to suggest a specific wheel, but you should be able to find a million threads about wheels for overweight cyclists (check bikeforums.net if you can't find enough here).

Also, I'd definitely buy used. You can get a 5-year-old bike for 1/3 the price of a comparable new bike. I'd look for a nice aluminum bike that's a few years old, and you'll be able to get a lot of bang for the buck.

"The melting point of wax means nothing to me": Thrice