Quantcast

Tri Training with NO CAFFINE?......Crazy? or Beneficial?

J.Michael's picture
Posts
128
Member
159 days
started by J.Michael on June 24, 2008

So, I'm new to the game of Tri's, but I know bits and pieces of nutrition. I'm sure many of you hardcore triathletes rival most nutritionists (sp?) in wealth of knowledge. So I ask....

Is there any benefit to training with no caffine? I mean none. Now, I'm not 100% sure what foods have natural amounts of caffine in them, but I try to stay clear of any source of the "people pepper upper."

I don't drink/eat any colas, coffee, teas, energy drinks, juice blends, vitamins, pills, chocolate, gels, drink(s), or drink mix that contains any caffine. I don't even take aspirin, ibuprophen, tylenol, ect.

I stick mostly with water, fresh juice, soy milk, and occasionally, some noncaffinated sodas (flattened by a mild shaking), ie sprite, 7up, ginger ale, rootbeer.

I haven't knowingly had any caffine in a few years now.

My question, is there any training benefit. I see people swigging sports drinks and gels loaded with the stuff. Is all that really needed?

I'm not looking to start drinking or eating foods ladened with the stuff anytime soon. I just wanted your opinion...

JB

jsk85's picture
Posts
668
Member
307 days
jsk85 posted 21 weeks ago.

I don't steer clear of caffiene and drink coffee in the mornings before work. I have only recently even looked at it as a possible aid before a race, but I don't train with it at all (unless you count residual leftover caffiene from the morning coffee). I haven't seen it limit me in any way, but I can't say for certain that I wouldn't be doing more with proper use of it.

I've heard it's better to only use it sparingly and possibly for races or high intensity stuff just b/c you develop resistance to it and just need to increase dosage to keep getting a similar effect....in the long run that doesn't seem like a good thing to me, so I'll just stick with using it for the morning work pep...since that's really what I need a boost to get me going for. Personal motivation is usually enough of a boost to get me through my workouts.

JMA's picture
Posts
109
Member
1226 days
JMA posted 21 weeks ago.

Here's an article about Caffeine and Endurance

I have a couple of cups of coffee most days. On race days I have coffee in the morning on the way to the race site. It gets me going and gets my pre-race activities moving.

I don't know if it has beneficial effects for me, but I know if I didn't have it I would suffer...withdrawal.

WillbIM1Day's picture
Posts
63
Member
215 days
WillbIM1Day posted 21 weeks ago.

I started training for my first marathon back in December 2006 and gave up caffeine (unintended coincidence since I was just trying to kick the cola habit). I haven't had a soda since.

I only drink decaf coffee (which has a tiny bit of caffeine in it) sparingly. Once one of my coworkers accidentally brought me back a caffeinated cup from Starbucks after a cubicle-coffee-run...I almost had to go home sick for the day. It made me nauseated, dizzy, hot, and shaky...that's what happens when you have a cup after not having it for 3 months.

Anyway, I haven't trained with caffeine (other than what's in a Gu) since December 2006 and I would never consider going back on caffeine for any potential "training" benefits.

zagfan's picture
Posts
181
Member
183 days
zagfan posted 21 weeks ago.

I've read articles on the benefits of caffeine in training and have had espresso every morning for the last year that I've been training. Part of it was habit, part of it was getting up at 4:45 in Colorado and wanting something warm. The amount of caffeine in the Gu's (25-50mg I believe) gives me just enough of a boost during the bike and run. I think it comes down to personal preference. There are so many nutrition plans out there that you just have to find what works for you. As long as you stay away from the big no-no's I think you'll be fine.

KitKat's picture
Posts
311
Member
659 days
KitKat posted 21 weeks ago.

I train with caffeine. I have it pre workout and usually in my gels or bars as well. 2-3 weeks before my race I cut back drastically, don't use it for training and limit myself to just one cup of coffee a day. Come race day I bring it back into my system. It may be completely mental but I feel it gives me the extra push I need.

Captain Mal's picture
Posts
157
Member
441 days
Captain Mal posted 21 weeks ago.

I don't do caffeine either. The one thing to remember is that caffeine is a diuretic. It may give you a boost, but if it boosts you into the porta-pottie when you want to be racing, you may have just surrendured your gains.
(By the way, I'm slow and the cost/benefit of a pee on the move just doesn't add up in my favor.)

"Faster would be better!" -Captain Mal, Serenity-

KitKat's picture
Posts
311
Member
659 days
KitKat posted 21 weeks ago.

It "boosts" me into the porta potty pre race :), gives a little jump start on things, then Dr. Immodium helps everything stay in place during racing.

brittda's picture
Posts
1764
Member
1394 days
brittda posted 21 weeks ago.

Ditto--I drink coffee like I have stock in Starbucks. The coffee helps things along in the morning pre race and by the time the race starts I am good to go, and have no fear of having to make a potty break. No need for immodium though. I do gu with/with out the caffiene and it does not affect my tummy at all.

StephenPDennis's picture
Posts
143
Member
185 days
StephenPDennis posted 21 weeks ago.

I work in construction management in Manhattan so I typically have 70-80 hour work weeks; coffee is mandatory. I typically have 5-6 cups a morning. I also have between 2-3 diet cola's a day on top of that. I have read more articles on caffeine intake for athletes than I can remember. It seems to me that the jury is still out on it's effects, some people say it gives them pep, I've even read several reports that it's diuretic effects are very over-hyped (I think there was something in Runner's World a month or two back that said they saw no increased urination at all in athletes after taking caffeine). Over all I think it's a personal choice, if you feel like caffeine hurts your performance, you're probably right. Me, caffeine is a trusted ally in my lifestyle so I haven't eliminated it.

TriSooner's picture
Posts
1187
Member
335 days
TriSooner posted 21 weeks ago.

JMA wrote:
It gets me going and gets my pre-race activities moving.
Please clarify. What do you mean? :)

J.Michael's picture
Posts
128
Member
159 days
J.Michael posted 21 weeks ago.

TriSooner wrote:
JMA wrote:
It gets me going and gets my pre-race activities moving.
Please clarify. What do you mean? :)

I think he's alluding to what you could call "a morning constitution."

or.....just plain old "paperwork" here around the office.

StephenPDennis's picture
Posts
143
Member
185 days
StephenPDennis posted 21 weeks ago.

As long as no one starts asking for pictures, I think this is fine.

J.Michael's picture
Posts
128
Member
159 days
J.Michael posted 21 weeks ago.

StephenPDennis wrote:
I work in construction management in Manhattan so I typically have 70-80 hour work weeks; coffee is mandatory. I typically have 5-6 cups a morning. I also have between 2-3 diet cola's a day on top of that. I have read more articles on caffeine intake for athletes than I can remember. It seems to me that the jury is still out on it's effects, some people say it gives them pep, I've even read several reports that it's diuretic effects are very over-hyped (I think there was something in Runner's World a month or two back that said they saw no increased urination at all in athletes after taking caffeine). Over all I think it's a personal choice, if you feel like caffeine hurts your performance, you're probably right. Me, caffeine is a trusted ally in my lifestyle so I haven't eliminated it.

I feel your pain in the 80hr/wk arena. I work in property management/rehab for multinational lenders, mainly dealing with bank owned homes/property. I've been in the office and out in the field for over 80hrs/wk since before new years.....

I'd hate to put my coworkers through me having more energy......they wouldn't make it thorugh a week.

StephenPDennis's picture
Posts
143
Member
185 days
StephenPDennis posted 21 weeks ago.

I think the 'in athletes' is a key to this forum. What I understand, physical exertion has a larger effect on the bodies water retention then caffeine. Based off of the latest article I've read, they seem to indicate that the body can veto Caffeine's diuretic abilities if you are active during it's effects, for example if you drink a mug right before a race. I was just following this thread if it helps... http://forums.runnersworld.com/eve/forums/a/tpc/f/504106038/m/7141018984

grindylow2000's picture
Posts
37
Member
173 days
grindylow2000 posted 21 weeks ago.

i drink a few cups of coffee per day and race/train with gels that have caffeine and some that dont. ive never had any kind of a GI issue or had to stop to answer natures call, i also have never really felt any considerable push from the caffeinated ones. during a 30 mile run i had a red bull at mi 15ish and that certainly hit the spot, picked me up and helped me maintain my stride.

i think that people that arent regular coffee drinkers or have never had coffee/caffeine, using gels and drinks infused with the stuff will certainly give you some tummy problems. as for the question of whether it is a diuretic or not, the jury is definitely still out on that. it seems runners world, inside triathlon, triathlete, bicycling, etc. magazines each have had an article in teh past year summarizing some study that (drum roll) turned up results that show there needs to be more studies done on the issue (really ground breaking stuff!!!!)

so for now, morning coffee, a morning run afternoon bike with a double espresso clif shot seems ok to me....

Anton's picture
Posts
2934
Member
1356 days
Anton posted 21 weeks ago.

Caffeine! You can sleep when you're dead!

"What would life be if we had no courage to attempt anything?" - Vincent Van Gogh
My Blog: http://agingsuperhero.blogspot.com

chris91180's picture
Posts
31
Member
226 days
chris91180 posted 21 weeks ago.

In high school a few of my cross country friends and I experimented with caffeine pills to see if it would improve our performance both training and racing. I don't remember what the dose was, probably a couple hundred milligrams. I remember it seemed to work very well in practice, but it made me sweat profusely - to the point that people noticed the difference. Forget the diuretic effect, you sweat out just as much (precious hydration). I used it for one race and it seemed to be working fine for the first 2 miles of the 5k, and then I totally blew up and ran out of gas, finishing with a slower than usual time. I never tried it again. Between the dehydration and elevated heart rate I was redlined. My friends quit it too.

As a pharmacist I know that its effects are not entirely different from ephedrine. Elevated heart rate, blood pressure and accelerated metabolism. That scares me despite the lack of cases of sudden death in athletes that we've seen from ephedrine. It may not be very dangerous at all, especially in low doses. Obviously many people consume large amounts of caffeine on a daily basis and triathletes typically have hearts of steel (iron for some). However, the long term effects of caffeine as an athletic performance supplement are not known. I got into this sport to improve my health, not to destroy it down the road (or now). My instincts tell me that supplementing with high doses of caffeine for training OR racing is just not a very good idea. I don't feel that low doses pose any danger, but I do question caffeine's effectiveness in endurance sports, especially for long course events (HIM and over). There is a tradeoff between the elevated heart rate and dehydration with the improved fuel burning. Just my opinion, but I think the jury is definitely still out on this one.

theShiba's picture
Posts
727
Member
524 days
theShiba posted 21 weeks ago.

Well, I'm sure you could do without Caffine, but I know most people would have a hard time without Caffeine.

TryScott's picture
Posts
556
Member
472 days
TryScott posted 21 weeks ago.

The articles I've read say that it varies a lot from person to person. I know we're all looking for an edge, but I'd advise that you don't take it just to perform better. If you want to perform better, training harder, longer, or smarter have been proven to increase your performance more than caffeine.

J.Michael's picture
Posts
128
Member
159 days
J.Michael posted 21 weeks ago.

theShiba wrote:
Well, I'm sure you could do without Caffine, but I know most people would have a hard time without Caffeine.

I think it's funny both owners of the company I work for drink 3 or 4 cups of starbucks a day. I don't mean they go in and get a small cup of joe either, they get a Venti with 3-4 extra shots (called a redeye or something like that) and they always talk about not having energy.....

I however, get up near 4-5am ride around 40-50 mi on the bike, shower, come into work by 8am, run on my lunch break or wait until I get off for the day (around 8-9pm), then stretch and I still have more go then they do at the end of the day...

I've come to believe that caffine only makes you think you have more energy and/or are more alert. I cannot deny the effect it has on the ol digestive system. I guess if thats' the only way you can stay "regular" then more power to you. I eat well (mostly veggies/fruit/nuts, and mostly raw), and I have no trouble with a "maka da doodie."

sorry if TMI.

beads1985's picture
Posts
4910
Member
1714 days
beads1985 posted 21 weeks ago.

Between working, parenting, and training I do need a little pick me up and enjoy a cup of coffee in the morning but I don't have it every day and I don't rely on it, but I don't exclude it either, ;-)

Nothing to it, but to do it

theShiba's picture
Posts
727
Member
524 days
theShiba posted 21 weeks ago.

theShiba wrote:
Well, I'm sure you could do without Caffine, but I know most people would have a hard time without CaffEIne.

Maybe if I do this, people will understand...

jtrimom's picture
Posts
578
Member
183 days
jtrimom posted 21 weeks ago.

a cup of coffee in the morning and a soda at lunch or I have a nasty headache. The only times I cut it out completely is when I was pregnant. But I do feel the "upper" effect after each "dose" - whether it's real or psychosomatic at this point is irrelevant

miner06's picture
Posts
39
Member
222 days
miner06 posted 21 weeks ago.

I'll have a cup of coffee in the morning during the week, but not usually on the weekends. I will generally stick with the gels that don't have caffeine, but I'll have a gel with caffeine near the end of a long workout to help me finish strong. I think the help is more in my head than being physical help.

"The only way to discover the limits of the possible is to go beyond them into the impossible."
- Arthur C. Clarke

diva_mom's picture
Posts
330
Member
254 days
diva_mom posted 21 weeks ago.

all things in moderation. i'm a user. green tea, coffee.

Don't be so easy on yourself 'cause this one might be all that you have left

kona_expat's picture
Posts
478
Member
1462 days
kona_expat posted 21 weeks ago.

I don't think anyone is better off with or without caffeine. It depends on your preferences.

Me personally? I drink a few cups of coffee in the morning. Habit I've had since college.

I tend not to add additional caffeine for training purposes until the spring. Once I start doing regular 5+ hour rides, I start using my custom Infinit mix that contains caffeine, and I might stop and pound down a Coke if I feel like it. For 2+ hour runs, I am generally drinking defizzed Coke, as that is what I will race with.

When I'm training about 17+ hours a week, well, I am just tired a lot, and several weekdays I will drink a can of either Coke or Mountain Dew Code Red right before a workout (maybe during in the case of swimming) just to perk me up.

Even though I drink coffee every day, I DO notice the impact of the Coke/Mt. Dew whenever I use it. Especially Mt. Dew vs. Coke (Mt. Dew has twice the caffeine of Coke).

I don't drink caffeinated beverages outside of my morning coffee or as either a pre-training or during training aid. So I'm pretty sure my body is metabolizing the stuff effectively.

Can it make it difficult to sleep? I don't really think so. When the caffeine is being metabolized during a workout, I find little residual effect except on 6+ hour training days, but then I would have it anyway because I'm just so jacked up in general.

If you have a moral objection to caffeine, then don't use it.

I do NOT notice any heart rate elevation. I don't believe that's a universal effect. Nor do I notice diuresis. Since I typically train quite a lot, I'm already peeing (and pooping!) a lot, so I couldn't tell you if there's more due to caffeine. But I do enjoy the way morning coffee "moves things along" as others have said, but it's just to keep myself on a schedule more than anything else :)

My n=1 experiment shows it DOES enhance my performance or at least my brain's perception of what I'm doing, and that in my book is priceless.

jess1's picture
Posts
169
Member
1199 days
jess1 posted 21 weeks ago.

J.Michael wrote:

I think it's funny both owners of the company I work for drink 3 or 4 cups of starbucks a day.

I think this is a key point to consider in your comparison.

Time flies like an arrow, fruit flies like a banana.

J.Michael's picture
Posts
128
Member
159 days
J.Michael posted 21 weeks ago.

jess1 wrote:
J.Michael wrote:

I think it's funny both owners of the company I work for drink 3 or 4 cups of starbucks a day.

I think this is a key point to consider in your comparison.

True, I agree that they are not your average coffee drinker.
Up until a few years ago, I would drink a few cups a day myself. I was burning the candle from both ends, you might say. I had a hectic job in B2B sales and long hours, long hours in a car, eating on the go, mental exhaustion, and stress were starting to take a toll on my overall health.

I'm not at all trying to come across saying that coffee/cola is a bad thing. I'm just trying to give it a go without any concentrated stimulants and I didn't know how many had already traveled down this path.

jess1's picture
Posts
169
Member
1199 days
jess1 posted 21 weeks ago.

No offense intended, maybe its a stereotype but I always picture the owner working twice as much as the employees and by the sounds of it you already had a intense job.

I'd love to cut back on coffee but its such has such a strong appeal. A nap in a cup!

Time flies like an arrow, fruit flies like a banana.

jess1's picture
Posts
169
Member
1199 days
jess1 posted 21 weeks ago.

No offense intended, maybe its a stereotype but I always picture the owner working twice as much as the employees and by the sounds of it you already had a intense job.

I'd love to cut back on coffee but its such has such a strong appeal. A nap in a cup!

Time flies like an arrow, fruit flies like a banana.

KitKat's picture
Posts
311
Member
659 days
KitKat posted 21 weeks ago.

jess1 wrote:

I'd love to cut back on coffee but its such has such a strong appeal. A nap in a cup!

LMAO, you should market that to Starbucks. What a great selling point!

beads1985's picture
Posts
4910
Member
1714 days
beads1985 posted 20 weeks ago.

KitKat wrote:
jess1 wrote:

I'd love to cut back on coffee but its such has such a strong appeal. A nap in a cup!

LMAO, you should market that to Starbucks. What a great selling point!

I like my coffee but Starbucks is all hype and too much$$
More like 'Crap in a cup'
The stuff I make at home or get at 7-11 or Quick Check is better and cheaper.

Nothing to it, but to do it

jsk85's picture
Posts
668
Member
307 days
jsk85 posted 20 weeks ago.

beads1985 wrote:

I like my coffee but Starbucks is all hype and too much$$
More like 'Crap in a cup'
The stuff I make at home or get at 7-11 or Quick Check is better and cheaper.

I agree to an extent...I think Starbucks is pretty tasty, but not to the point that makes it financially worth it over regular home drip coffee. My uncle swears by it...he even had it shipped to him overseas when he worked there for a while.
I usually only go for starbucks when I'm on the road, or REALLY need a boost...for some reason it seems to get me more wired than regular coffee. I think it has more caffeine, but have never heard any proof.

KitKat's picture
Posts
311
Member
659 days
KitKat posted 20 weeks ago.

beads1985 wrote:
KitKat wrote:
jess1 wrote:

I'd love to cut back on coffee but its such has such a strong appeal. A nap in a cup!

LMAO, you should market that to Starbucks. What a great selling point!

I like my coffee but Starbucks is all hype and too much$$
More like 'Crap in a cup'
The stuff I make at home or get at 7-11 or Quick Check is better and cheaper.

Sorry just used them as an example. :/
I like making my own french press at home :).
But 7-11......Ewwwwwwwwww