Quantcast

Why do I keep getting dropped on the hills?

WillbIM1Day's picture
Posts
63
Member
175 days
started by WillbIM1Day on May 13, 2008

So I'm in Central Park this morning doing a 60-minute tempo ride, feeling pretty good about myself after 6 miles. This guy and what appeared to be a friend of his that he was teaching about pacelines (they were on a nice pair of Jamis') start drafting behind me. They stayed behind me for another 6 miles.

Then about a third of the way through my last loop, they both pass me going up one of the two major hills in the Park and one of the guys taps me on the shoulder and says, "just a little bit of friendly advice...never decrease on the hills always increase. That'll prevent you from going backwards like you are now."

I was totally pissed! At first I was thinking what the heck was this guy doing drafting on me for 6 miles if he thinks I'm such a terrible rider? And then I thought about it some more when I got to work this morning...it's just the hills. I AM ALWAYS GETTING DROPPED ON THE HILLS.

What did the guy mean and what am I doing wrong? I rarely feel like I'm getting dropped on the flats and almost never on the downhills, but I haven't got the mechanics down yet on the uphill. Could it be that I just need to do more hill repeats, or am I totally using the wrong gear ratios?

gfd's picture
Posts
664
Member
985 days
gfd posted 21 weeks ago.

I am guessing that he meant cadence. Your speed, well at least my speed, will inevitably decrease going uphill. Dropping gears to correspond with keeping your cadence in the 80 to 90 range should help you from falling back on the shorter uphills.

kkocan's picture
Posts
372
Member
843 days
kkocan posted 21 weeks ago.

He may have meant something else. We have a guy in the local group ride that whenever he is on a climb and he switches gears and or goes from sitting to standing or vice-versa he lets up and drops back a good foot or so. If you are riding behind him you will often time come close to rear-ending him. We've told him numerous times to watch out and tried to show him how he 'backs up' all the time on hills but he just doesn't grasp it.

Maybe that's what the guy was talking about, since he was teaching his buddy about pace-line riding.

________________________________________________
2008 Main Races:
VA Beach Shamrock Marathon
Desoto TTT
WV Mountaineer HIM
IM Wisconsin

PrinceofClydes's picture
Posts
1704
Member
1487 days
PrinceofClydes posted 21 weeks ago.

I'm almost certain that's what buddy meant.
Practice counting cadence when you can measure it, say, when you're relaxing at home.
15 counts in 10 secs would be 90rpm
Compare that with the one per second: one one thousand, two one thousand, we learned as kids and see what your cadence is on the hills.
Choose a gear that gets you closer to the 90rpm on a given hill, then teach yourself to get used to that.

btw, Was he wearing a shirt that read, "Don't hate me 'cos I suck wheels" ?

heh.

PoC

"Pain doesn't last, chicks dig scars, glory is forever!"
- Shane Falco.

TriSooner's picture
Posts
1068
Member
295 days
TriSooner posted 21 weeks ago.

WillbIM1Day wrote:
. . . one of the guys taps me on the shoulder and says, "just a little bit of friendly advice...never decrease on the hills always increase. That'll prevent you from going backwards like you are now."
You are a better man than I for not grabbing a handfull of bar and twisting him to the ground. Seriously, a beat down was in order. First, did you ask his opinion on your riding? Second, if he was such a bad ass, why was he drafting off of you? Finally, THIS is why cyclists suck. You weren't doing anything wrong: This dork was. If he was drafting off of you, and you two clearly didn't even know each other and had never ridden together, he should know that he rides at his own risk. Drafting off of someone you've never riden behind? Buyer beware.

ChunkyB's picture
Posts
997
Member
360 days
ChunkyB posted 21 weeks ago.

Yeah, I would have stuck my frame pump in his spokes.

I bet he was talking about cadence. I think one thing that people learn when they get a power meter ir how much power they waste on hills. Especially in races, I think you're better off going to a super low gear on the uphills and just spinning like crazy, and then blowing by all the people that passed you on the downhill because they're all gasping for air.

"The melting point of wax means nothing to me": Thrice

My Blog

deepbluex's picture
Posts
668
Member
1100 days
deepbluex posted 21 weeks ago.

The thing about hills is:
-shift to easier gear to maintain fast cadence
-remain seated if at all possible
-concentrate on circular pedaling motion rather than pumping up and down
-travel light. uphill is where bike, rider, and cargo weight will slow you down.

Anton's picture
Posts
2826
Member
1316 days
Anton posted 21 weeks ago.

Wheel suckers..ARRGH! Don't even get me started...
Ya wanna grab my wheel...? Fine. Ask first, then you sure as hell better take your pull at the front...MAN! He would have deserved an asphalt sandwich if you would have bumped and he'd gone down. And the unsolicited advice? Unless your Jens Voight, don't give it. I hate those guys...ARRGH...
(ok, so I had a bad day at school and I'm taking it out on wheel suckers...)

"What would life be if we had no courage to attempt anything?" - Vincent Van Gogh
My Blog: http://agingsuperhero.blogspot.com

WillbIM1Day's picture
Posts
63
Member
175 days
WillbIM1Day posted 21 weeks ago.

Aside from the good advice you guys are giving, it's REALLY nice to hear that I'm not alone in thinking the guy was a total jerk. Thanks all.

I was already in the lowest gear when he passed me, so I guess I managed to lower my cadence even though I was already in easy mode...I think I need to (1) get a computer to keep tabs on my cadence and (2) consider getting a new cassette (maybe from 12-25 to 12-27).

I would love to keep training and see the guy in the park again one day, kick his butt on an uphill and utter "You were saying?" over my shoulder as he eats my dust.

GGehrke's picture
Posts
187
Member
297 days
GGehrke posted 21 weeks ago.

+1 that the guy's a total douche.

One thing to consider, though, is weight. I am not implying anything, but a larger rider will invariably struggle in the hills, leading to a feeling of "keep getting dropped."

I say this because I am, to my detriment, sometimes the counter-example. In a recent race (Sea Otter Classic Circuit race on Laguna Seca, which has one NASTY hill and lots of wind) I would find myself wasting the pack in the climb and getting dropped on the descent and subsequently staying dropped on the flats. Because I was the smallest rider in the bunch, I had an easier time on the hills but didn't have the raw power to keep up on the flats. If you've got powerful legs and a larger frame, you'll hold your own on the flats (advantageous for most tri's) even if others are sneaking by you on the climbs. Moral of the story is that it should all come out in the wash. All those guys who I passed in the hills came back past me and I finished 3rd from DFL. I wouldn't worry too much.

ChunkyB's picture
Posts
997
Member
360 days
ChunkyB posted 21 weeks ago.

Honestly, I think everyone here (including me) is understating what a jerk that dude was. What a loser for giving you "friendly advice" after drafting off of you for 6 miles. If you ever see the guy again, make sure to tell him the the rest of the world agrees that he's a total loser and he should shut his mouth next time he passes someone on his bike.

I weigh ~255, so if there's anything I hate, it's hills. Do you have a triple chainring? Honestly, I know it's wussy and everything to use your granny gear, but I love it. If you don't have one, then a different cassette would be the cheapest way to get some lower gears, or you might consider getting a compact crankset. Just some ideas, but if you're only doing this because of what that douche bag said, then I would just forget it. My $0.02.

"The melting point of wax means nothing to me": Thrice

My Blog

ChunkyB's picture
Posts
997
Member
360 days
ChunkyB posted 21 weeks ago.

ChunkyB wrote:
Honestly, I think everyone here (including me) is understating what a jerk that dude was. What a loser for giving you "friendly advice" after drafting off of you for 6 miles. If you ever see the guy again, make sure to tell him the the rest of the world agrees that he's a total loser and he should shut his mouth next time he passes someone on his bike.

I weigh ~255, so if there's anything I hate, it's hills. Do you have a triple chainring? Honestly, I know it's wussy and everything to use your granny gear, but I love it. If you don't have one, then a different cassette would be the cheapest way to get some lower gears, or you might consider getting a compact crankset. Just some ideas, but if you're only doing this because of what that douche bag said, then I would just forget it and stick with what you have. My $0.02.

"The melting point of wax means nothing to me": Thrice

My Blog

deepbluex's picture
Posts
668
Member
1100 days
deepbluex posted 21 weeks ago.

Of course the guy was a total jerk! Dispensing advice is something you do carefully. If nobody is asking for advice, then giving it like that is a total asshole move. Also, never ever touch someone unless it's ok to do so. I would have put my cleat in his face! Are you kidding me?! Wheelsucker at that. Sheesh. I'd be posting "Today I went to jail because I beat someone up using parts of his own bicycle"

cayman's picture
Posts
800
Member
784 days
cayman posted 21 weeks ago.

WillbIM1Day wrote:
I would love to keep training and see the guy in the park again one day, kick his butt on an uphill and utter "You were saying?" over my shoulder as he eats my dust.

Don't waste your energy on the guys in the park, they all think their Lance Armstrong. It's easy to be good on a 6 mile loop if that's all you do-- ever watch hamsters?

More hill work, more better.

john
Pain is inevitable. Suffering is optional.

tri-ac's picture
Posts
1715
Member
1037 days
tri-ac posted 21 weeks ago.

sigh, I miss nyc

stewarba's picture
Posts
435
Member
453 days
stewarba posted 21 weeks ago.

This thread is awesome - After reading the OP, I was thinking that I would have jumped right of the bike and took him down (even at 25 MPH), but after reading some of the responses, I don't have too.

Pain is the sensation of weakness leaving the body!

GGehrke's picture
Posts
187
Member
297 days
GGehrke posted 21 weeks ago.

ChunkyB wrote:
Do you have a triple chainring? Honestly, I know it's wussy and everything to use your granny gear, but I love it.

I <3 my granny gear.

deepbluex's picture
Posts
668
Member
1100 days
deepbluex posted 21 weeks ago.

I have a granny gear on my road bike w/ a triple. When I know there are some particularly steep hills on a race course, I'll take the road bike instead of the tri bike with the dual chainrings. Better to climb easy than to either walk/push the bike up or kill your legs doing the climb and end up with dead running legs coming into T2.

jbird2131's picture
Posts
181
Member
410 days
jbird2131 posted 21 weeks ago.

Seems like everyone is giving you great advice! I just wanted to chime in on calling out this douche. Whatta tool.

PrinceofClydes's picture
Posts
1704
Member
1487 days
PrinceofClydes posted 21 weeks ago.

Sounds like road rage is alive and well, even among cyclists!

I know it's easy to heap abuse on some poor bastard two thousand miles away but I hope this little venting isn't going to endorse any violence between fellow cyclists however misguided they may be. For all we know he's a kindergarten teacher who merely lacks a little tactfulness. I mean there's only so many words you can say in the five seconds as you pass someone and I'm certainly not suggesting that he was without blame for it but aren't we overreacting?

I'd rather take th ehigh road. Take his advice, get better and sometime down the road, when he's having a bad day, or is fixing a flat on the roadside, stop and help him and thank him for the inspiration he gave you to get better.

If you can't do that, if you can't curb your aggression or channel it into positive gains, take up hockey where it's not only approved of, but is even admired.

$.02

PoC

"Pain doesn't last, chicks dig scars, glory is forever!"
- Shane Falco.

deepbluex's picture
Posts
668
Member
1100 days
deepbluex posted 21 weeks ago.

I can't believe what jerks kindergarten teachers can be!

PrinceofClydes's picture
Posts
1704
Member
1487 days
PrinceofClydes posted 21 weeks ago.

LOL!

PoC

"Pain doesn't last, chicks dig scars, glory is forever!"
- Shane Falco.

Sully800's picture
Posts
427
Member
386 days
Sully800 posted 21 weeks ago.

I don't have a cadence meter but I know for sure I am a masher. All you people and your high cadence posts drive me crazy, because I feel like I lose all sorts of power if I even approach 90 rpm. Despite my mashing tendencies I don't think I'm a particularly bad climber, so perhaps I am just suited to a lower cadence. You can call me Jan, especially because I frequently wear a Tmobile jersey ;-)

PrinceofClydes's picture
Posts
1704
Member
1487 days
PrinceofClydes posted 21 weeks ago.

Sully800 wrote:
I don't have a cadence meter but I know for sure I am a masher. All you people and your high cadence posts drive me crazy, because I feel like I lose all sorts of power if I even approach 90 rpm. Despite my mashing tendencies I don't think I'm a particularly bad climber, so perhaps I am just suited to a lower cadence. You can call me Jan, especially because I frequently wear a Tmobile jersey ;-)

Try proving it to yourself by riding the same hill several times, perhaps over several days to even out the fatigue factor, in different gears at different cadences and measure the times. Better yet get someone else to measure the times to make it a blind study.

Then remember that it isn't always about how fast you get up one hill. It may be about how much one hill, climbed badly, thrashes your quads and drains the energy you need for the rest of the race.

Think tortoise and hare.

PoC

"Pain doesn't last, chicks dig scars, glory is forever!"
- Shane Falco.

Sully800's picture
Posts
427
Member
386 days
Sully800 posted 21 weeks ago.

Yeah, it might be helpful to do hill repeats at different cadences and compare the results. But one thing to keep in mind (directed toward everyone) is that not everyone is built like Lance Armstrong. Each person has a different ideal cadence, and just because he ushered in a era of super spinners doesn't mean everyone should try to replicate how he rode. Armstrong and Ullrich were the two best cyclists in the world for a while and used drastically different cadences which was very evident during their climbing showdowns.

Do powermeter users have a way of finding their ideal cadence with the meter? Just curious because I don't know much about the different ways that power meters are used...

ChunkyB's picture
Posts
997
Member
360 days
ChunkyB posted 21 weeks ago.

Sully800 wrote:
Yeah, it might be helpful to do hill repeats at different cadences and compare the results. But one thing to keep in mind (directed toward everyone) is that not everyone is built like Lance Armstrong. Each person has a different ideal cadence, and just because he ushered in a era of super spinners doesn't mean everyone should try to replicate how he rode. Armstrong and Ullrich were the two best cyclists in the world for a while and used drastically different cadences which was very evident during their climbing showdowns.

Do powermeter users have a way of finding their ideal cadence with the meter? Just curious because I don't know much about the different ways that power meters are used...

+ a lot.

I weigh 255, and I'm not sloppy fat or anything. I'm fat, but I'm also just big boned, and I don't think that riding like lance would be the best approach for me. For some people, they're better off using their strength to hammer. Anyways, I totally agree.

"The melting point of wax means nothing to me": Thrice

My Blog

PrinceofClydes's picture
Posts
1704
Member
1487 days
PrinceofClydes posted 21 weeks ago.

Big boned. heh. I like that.

I'm 6'2" 220 myself. The Lance / Jan comparison is misleading. It suggests that there are two riding styles (at least) and you are either one or the other.

It's possible, I think likely, that Jan is the freak, not Lance.
Do we muggles have more in common with Lance or with Jan Ullrich. Even Lance thought that Jan was the most talented bike racer in the world. Even if he was blowing smoke up Jan's tailpipe to placate the beast, he may have been right.

Spinning puts the emphasis on the heart / lung capacity, grinding larger gears stresses the quads and butt directly. In the latter case the capacity of the muscles to drive the big gears up a mountain is limited by the ATP stores in the muscles (locally), and the ATP stores in the liver - available as blood borne glycogen, then... you crash. Jan was totally freaky (or had a good chemist).

You and I can more readily access energy stored in fat by raising the oxygen intake through employing higher cadences than we can magically find more glycogen in muscle / liver stores. When that tank is empty, it's empty. Recovery from muscle exhaustion is much slower (hours) than recovery from oxygen debt (getting out of breath).

In summary, through training you and I will become more efficient, more quickly, by improving our ability to ride higher cadences and smaller gears than by trying to "Ride like Jan."

$.02

PoC

"Pain doesn't last, chicks dig scars, glory is forever!"
- Shane Falco.

Sully800's picture
Posts
427
Member
386 days
Sully800 posted 21 weeks ago.

And thats a pretty good reason that I'd be better at powering through hills, because I started as a sprinter in track and was never as successful in the long events. Of course in long course tri's you cannot simply muscle through a hill because you will be spent before the run, but in general riding it seems to work best for me. It's also important to note that you should practice your weaknesses, so I should continue to work on my endurance and try to spin at higher cadences.

As for Jan or Lance being the freak, its plain that they both were. I don't know about cadences of most riders, but wasn't Lance one of the first to use super high cadences? I was under the impression that he sparked a bit of a revolution in regards to spinning up hills..

PrinceofClydes's picture
Posts
1704
Member
1487 days
PrinceofClydes posted 21 weeks ago.

Sully800 wrote:
..

As for Jan or Lance being the freak, its plain that they both were. I don't know about cadences of most riders, but wasn't Lance one of the first to use super high cadences? I was under the impression that he sparked a bit of a revolution in regards to spinning up hills..

Lance supposedly learned about high cadences on the hills from no less than Miguel Indurain Here's a story from 1995 on a day when Lance finished 15 minutes behind Miguel during Indurain's Five Consecutive Tour win.

Another article on climbing tips including a reference to Miguel's cadence.
PoC

"Pain doesn't last, chicks dig scars, glory is forever!"
- Shane Falco.

iamtb13's picture
Posts
217
Member
179 days
iamtb13 posted 20 weeks ago.

So there I was out doing my long (2.5 hours since I only race sprint and olympic distances) ride this morning on the W&O bike trail out in Northern Virginia. I was crusiing along in my Z1 heart rate enjoying a beautiful morning. Then I hit a big bump and my speedometer magnet got loose so I pulled over to quickly fix it. Suddenly a pace line of 6 flashily dressed riders rolled by nicely tucked behind each other. I suddenly remembed this thread and wonder if perhaps these might be the same riders from Central Park now down in Virginia. I reasoned it could be and that someone should teach them a lesson. With magnet fixed and ego intact, I climbed back on and decided Z1 is for wimps. They had dropped one rider and as I closed on him I wondered what to say. Taking the high triathlete road I said, "Come on, we can catch them." He wasn't up for it.
I caught the other 5 about a mile down the trail. I hung on the back and got some water and Infinity as they sprinted up a short hill. I stayed behind as we crested the top and went down the other side before beginning a gradual 2 mile climb. (Pacelines aren't so effective uphills ;) )
As soon as we hit the bottom and started up, I pulled to the front. Only saying "on your left" in polite fashion as I went by. Now at the front I wondered what some of my other TriFuelers would do...
theShiba...open my water bottle and casually squirt it over my shoulder as I pretended to sneeze.
tribro...ask about possible advertising possibilities on Trifuel
UFTriGator...go faster.
While all good options, I opted for UFTriGator. I was just crossing Z4a for those of you keep score at home and I heard the guy behind me say "Let's go!" as I picked up the pace on the uphill. My legs were burning big time but I kept saying to myself, "I am a triathlete. I do pain" and off we went. One mile up the hill and I glance back. Only two guys still behind me. Z4b now and my coach isn't going to like this...but sometimes you just gotta feed the fragile male ego.
By the time I hit the top of the 2 mile uphill there wasn't a soul behind me. My legs killed, I thought I was going to puke but darn if I didn't feel good. (I had 7 miles left and kept a good pace to make sure they didn't regroup but there was no sign of them.)
I won't be able to walk later tonight but I feel good knowing there are 6 "fancy bike guys" who have sore legs AND bruised egos. (and I bet they can't swim either!)

azmojo804's picture
Posts
144
Member
161 days
azmojo804 posted 20 weeks ago.

iamtb13, that just brought a very nice, huge grin on my face...brightened my day! Nice job! I think the only thing that would have made it better would have been if the guy they dropped would have stayed with you and kicked the other 5 butt's too! :)

gfd's picture
Posts
664
Member
985 days
gfd posted 20 weeks ago.

Very well written. Made me smile.

PrinceofClydes's picture
Posts
1704
Member
1487 days
PrinceofClydes posted 20 weeks ago.

iamtb13,
Nothing wrong with that, that I can see. At least you kept your mouth shut and didn't say anything you'd regret later.

Take your inspiration where you can find it.
Channel it in a positive direction to, you know, keep good kharma.

Ommmmmm...

PoC

"Pain doesn't last, chicks dig scars, glory is forever!"
- Shane Falco.

RV's picture
Posts
3349
Member
1360 days
RV posted 20 weeks ago.

iamtb13 - ya that is quite a, story...

RV

It takes a long time to get good. - Scott Molina
Slow is smooth; smooth is fast. - Rich Strauss

ChunkyB's picture
Posts
997
Member
360 days
ChunkyB posted 20 weeks ago.

PrinceofClydes wrote:
Big boned. heh. I like that.

I'm 6'2" 220 myself. The Lance / Jan comparison is misleading. It suggests that there are two riding styles (at least) and you are either one or the other.

It's possible, I think likely, that Jan is the freak, not Lance.
Do we muggles have more in common with Lance or with Jan Ullrich. Even Lance thought that Jan was the most talented bike racer in the world. Even if he was blowing smoke up Jan's tailpipe to placate the beast, he may have been right.

I'm pretty sure it's the other way around, considering the other riders in the TdF were also riding a lower cadence like Jan. That's why everyone always made such a big deal about Lance's cadence. If Jan were the freak, they would have been talking about him.

And, I don't think the point is to say that there are only two correct riding styles. The point I was trying to make is that you shouldn't believe everyone who tells you that your cadence needs to be at least 90, and throw out numbers like their average cadence is 125 and crap like that. That's one way to ride (and to go insane), but you could also be successful with a cadence of 80 or 85 or 75 or 60 (or ~35 which is usually what I do up the hills). It just depends.

I just get tired of everyone and their dog saying that everyone should ride above 90 just because Lance did and Jan didn't (and, for the record, on hills he was usually just under 90, not above it). He won lots of TdF's, but it isn't just because he had a high cadence. It also wasn't because he was riding a Trek, even though Trek dealers would like you to believe that. It was because, first of all, he has freakishly big lungs/heart/VO2 max/etc. Second of all, it was because he was probably the most disciplined cyclist in recent history. Also, he trained specifically for the Tour and nothing else. And I'm sure those are just a few of the reasons. He had tons of natural talent, and he devoted his whole life to winning the Tour. That's a pretty good mix. But I guess since we can't all copy his VO2 max, we could at least copy his high cadence (or his habit of weighing his food).

"The melting point of wax means nothing to me": Thrice

My Blog

RV's picture
Posts
3349
Member
1360 days
RV posted 20 weeks ago.

For triathlon it is helpful if your cycling cadence is the same as your run cadence - mot people run at about 85-90 - hence where the cycling cadence is recommended.

It took me a full season to get comfortable riding at a higher cadence - I used to be at 75-80 - now 90-95. For me it certainly eased the transition from biking to running.

Tho best is just to get out there and do it.

RV

It takes a long time to get good. - Scott Molina
Slow is smooth; smooth is fast. - Rich Strauss