Quantcast

Cars and the Price of Gas

tsilcyc's picture
Posts
872
Member
1238 days
started by tsilcyc on April 29, 2008

This is going to be as generic as asking you're favorite color but I'm looking at buying a new car and the price of gas is making me reconsider what I want.

I've been thinking about something economical but it has to hold two bikes on the inside. So what's your ride and how well does it hold bikes?

-------------------------------------------------------------------
Check out my Log: http://www.felog.net/users/teamsln/query_log.aspx
Check out my Blog: http://www.felog.net/feblog/

azstinger11's picture
Posts
459
Member
1096 days
azstinger11 posted 1 year ago.

Ack your right I forgot my friend traded in his Si for the hybrid about 2 months ago when he had the conversation on mpg, but having just called him to ask he said he was averaging around 30 which is still really good for such a fun car, and he could get in the upper 30s on long flatter road trips.

-----------------------------------------------
Base 1 (Week 2, 16.5hrs)
Check out my blog!

Jay's picture
Posts
49
Member
587 days
Jay posted 1 year ago.

i thought i had read somewhere that honda axed there hybrid lineup. so that means the suport and parts could become harder to come by.

if i was buying new today, i would be looking at subaru's, suzuki XL7, or a volvo wagon.
my sis has a forester and it is pretty great, she doe slive in aus. though.

Socket's picture
Posts
755
Member
911 days
Socket posted 1 year ago.

The civic hybrid doesn't get 50. You could go the hypermiler route and then maybe you'd get 50+...

Socket's picture
Posts
755
Member
911 days
Socket posted 1 year ago.

accidental double post. my bad.

FlashRedGLS1.8T's picture
Posts
179
Member
933 days
FlashRedGLS1.8T posted 1 year ago.

azstinger11 wrote:
Ack your right I forgot my friend traded in his Si for the hybrid about 2 months ago when he had the conversation on mpg, but having just called him to ask he said he was averaging around 30 which is still really good for such a fun car, and he could get in the upper 30s on long flatter road trips.

Totally agree with that. The hybrid can get some major MPG.

FlashRedGLS1.8T's picture
Posts
179
Member
933 days
FlashRedGLS1.8T posted 1 year ago.

Jay wrote:
i thought i had read somewhere that honda axed there hybrid lineup. so that means the suport and parts could become harder to come by.

They axed the Accord Hybrid. You can still get the Civic Hybrid.

tritoride28's picture
Posts
80
Member
583 days
tritoride28 posted 1 year ago.

Flash Red is right. Honda got rid of the accord Hybrid because it did not fair as well against the Camry Hybrid as they would have hoped. Their electrical system did not operate nearly as efficiently as the Toyota's did. The Saturn Aura Hybrid system is the cheapest system on the market right now, but didnt get nearly as high of a rating as the Camry or Altima Hybrids.

Sully800's picture
Posts
444
Member
794 days
Sully800 posted 1 year ago.

I'm pretty sure Honda only got rid of the Accord Hybrid and kept the Civic Hybrid. That makes sense because it wasn't fairing that well against the camry and didn't get nearly as good mileage as the civic....and since people in the market for hybrid cars are generally looking for the best fuel economy, they scrapped the accord.

ChunkyB's picture
Posts
1037
Member
768 days
ChunkyB posted 1 year ago.

Captain Mal wrote:
tsilcyc wrote:
FJ Cruiser - This just smells of testosterone.

Hee hee.

Sorry Cap'n, I just had to put the actual picture on this thread. I love that picture. I've never been more proud to be your brother.

"The melting point of wax means nothing to me": Thrice

Ryan's picture
Posts
60
Member
1598 days
Ryan posted 1 year ago.

I'm very biased because I actually work for a big 3 Auto maker in Detroit. I cant believe how much of you around the country don't have any pride in buying American, especially when the economy is as bad as it these days. American Quality is on Par with the Hondas and Toyotas (much more than in years passed).

Hybrids are expensive and are for cities (stop and go drivers). The hybrid (electric) portion of the engine is only in use when you are driving under 20 MPH. Anything over that the gas portion of the engine kicks in and the car drinks GAS. Many people complain that they don’t like the Hybrid fuel economy because they drive freeways and they never utilize the hybrid portion. Wait at least two more years for a hybrid, the prices will be going down about 5k-8k (inside info)

The best new options I recommend for Triathletes are the Dodge Caliber, Pontiac Vibe. These cars can get up to about 28 MPG and still have room when you fold the seats down. Its basically like a small SUV but drive more like a car. Plus they have cool functions like the chilled cupholders, coolers for ice, etc.

Forza Nerazzurri

Ryan's picture
Posts
60
Member
1598 days
Ryan posted 1 year ago.

ChunkyB wrote:
Captain Mal wrote:
tsilcyc wrote:
FJ Cruiser - This just smells of testosterone.

Hee hee.

Sorry Cap'n, I just had to put the actual picture on this thread. I love that picture. I've never been more proud to be your brother.


I hate to rip on the FJ. But the pecking order for rock crawlers is
#1 Jeep
#2 Hummer
#3 Land Rover

Its hard to take pride in a asian crawler

Forza Nerazzurri

kylie's picture
Posts
5318
Member
1999 days
kylie posted 1 year ago.

Ryan wrote:
I'm very biased because I actually work for a big 3 Auto maker in Detroit. I cant believe how much of you around the country don't have any pride in buying American, especially when the economy is as bad as it these days. American Quality is on Par with the Hondas and Toyotas (much more than in years passed).

For me it has nothing to do with American Pride. We live in a global market place, and as a consumer I'm going to buy the goods that I believe are right for me, especially with a purchase as large as a car. And while I believe that the American car quality is going up, I don't think it is yet on par with Honda and Toyota. And I have test driven them, and didn't like them as much even just from a new, single ride perspective.

Miles of Life --- Powered by MarkyV

Captain Mal's picture
Posts
195
Member
808 days
Captain Mal posted 1 year ago.

Ryan wrote:


I hate to rip on the FJ. But the pecking order for rock crawlers is
#1 Jeep
#2 Hummer
#3 Land Rover

Its hard to take pride in a asian crawler

I'll be sure to take that with the grain of salt that comes with you working for one of the big three.

Jeep - not to happy with the reliability and would never pay 30+k for one. Plus, Jeep lost one of its best selling points when it significantly lengthened the wheelbase. Still, hard to argue with a sold front axle and that electronic sway disconnect is pretty cool. I would only get a Jeep if it were an oldie but goodie. Even then, I would be looking at FJ-40's first.

Hummer - I love my neighbor's H1, but GM ruined the Hummer. At least they started puting an engine in the H3 that could actually pull it. By the way, what is the logic behind putting rock rails under nerf bars anyway? You get to protect the body in the event you rip the nerfs entirely off?

Land Rover - Too expensive and I just don't like the look. Would take a Land Cruiser any day of the week over a Land Rover.

Anyway, I like my little blue asian and I will keep rolling it and be proud of it.

"Faster would be better!" -Captain Mal, Serenity-

Jay's picture
Posts
49
Member
587 days
Jay posted 1 year ago.

don't confuse your new toyota FJ with a land cruiser. the older cruisers were great as are jeeps. but the new fj is a diferent beast. if ya like it, then good on ya.

as for the comment on the american built vehicles comparingt o the asian ones, the asian cars/trucks hold there value much better than anything american. and they just plain last longer int eh engine department. imports also usually have nicer creature comforts than the american built stuff

Captain Mal's picture
Posts
195
Member
808 days
Captain Mal posted 1 year ago.

Jay wrote:
don't confuse your new toyota FJ with a land cruiser. the older cruisers were great as are jeeps. but the new fj is a diferent beast. if ya like it, then good on ya.

Yeah, I was not trying to confuse the new FJ with the Land Cruisers. I think the new FJ is more like a 4Runner than a Land Cruiser.

I was just comparing the old Land Cruisers to older Jeeps and the newer Land Cruisers to what I see in the Land Rovers. The new FJ is certainly not the king of the hill even in Toyota's line-up, but it is a fun ride for what I use it for.

"Faster would be better!" -Captain Mal, Serenity-

Triguy98's picture
Posts
2807
Member
1686 days
Triguy98 posted 1 year ago.

I drive a Focus hatch back and a 92 Jeep Wrangler. I love my jeep, I can do pretty much anything- especially that highway that FJ is rolling on ;) But it gets 17 mpg. Good thing my commute is short for now. The Focus gets ~30 mpg average with a mix of highway/ in town. You can stack3 bikes in the back, laying on their side with the front wheels off. I have a Saris Rack for the back. MPG goes down a little with 3 bikes on the back, but its not too bad. I like the Mazda 3 more than the Focus, based on styling and transmission, but realistically theyre pretty close. I got my Focus for a lot less than I could get a 3.

We're moving at the end of the year, and my commute is getting longer. I am buying a motorcycle for that. Cant top 50mpg.

Life is short. Play hard and get dirty doing it.

tsilcyc's picture
Posts
872
Member
1238 days
tsilcyc posted 1 year ago.

Ryan wrote:
I'm very biased because I actually work for a big 3 Auto maker in Detroit. I cant believe how much of you around the country don't have any pride in buying American, especially when the economy is as bad as it these days.

Let's see... before I owned my Tacoma, I owned a Jeep Cherokee. The Tacoma has a 6 year 72,000 mile warranty, the Jeep had a three year 36,000 mile warranty. Right off the bat, I like the fact that Toyota will stand behind their product better than a US based company. I just looked up Jeep warranty and it is still the same.

I did buy American and here's what happened: I serviced my Jeep every 3K miles to the letter at the dealership. I had a problem that mysteriously kept turning into something else each time I took it in. You see, California has a lemon law which dealerships can get around by not having it be the same problem. This same dealership managed to get this problem outside of the warranty and then threw me under the bus. I wrote Chrysler who apologized but did nothing. I wrote the State of California who did nothing. Ultimately I wound up taking a loss on a vehicle which had only 45,000 miles in less than two years. I traded it in for my Tacoma which now has 175,000 miles and is running quite well.

On the opposite end of the spectrum, I had a problem with work the Toyota dealership did and not only did they not charge me for the labor, they also didn't charge me for the parts. While this has nothing to do with the automaker, I'm sure it has something to do with good management practices which are from the top down.

There is a large Toyota plant in Fremont, CA. While these are technically Japanese cars, they are manufactured in Fremont and employing a number of workers in bay area. I also know of a large Nissan plant outside of Nashville. I'm assuming there are other plants in other states and as well. These plants contribute to the local and US economy but probably not doing much for Detroit.

I can empathize with the people of Detroit (or Flint as in the case of GM) but at the same time, the manufacturers need to not only build a better product, they need to stand behind it.

-------------------------------------------------------------------
Check out my Log: http://www.felog.net/users/teamsln/query_log.aspx
Check out my Blog: http://www.felog.net/feblog/

Sully800's picture
Posts
444
Member
794 days
Sully800 posted 1 year ago.

Ryan wrote:
Hybrids are expensive and are for cities (stop and go drivers). The hybrid (electric) portion of the engine is only in use when you are driving under 20 MPH. Anything over that the gas portion of the engine kicks in and the car drinks GAS. Many people complain that they don’t like the Hybrid fuel economy because they drive freeways and they never utilize the hybrid portion. Wait at least two more years for a hybrid, the prices will be going down about 5k-8k (inside info)

This is simply not true, especially because you overlook the difference between different types of hybrids. The prius primarily uses an electric motor, with the gasoline engine assisting when more power is needed. I don't own the prius, but I would imagine that is where the figure of 20 mph keeps coming from (that it operates solely on the electric motor under 20 mph).

The civic hybrid on the other hand uses a gasoline engine primarily and the electric motor comes on when more power is needed (when accelerating or going up hills). Since you accelerate and go up hills on highways and back roads, you get a significant mpg boost even when you are not in the city. In addition to the regenerative braking, the civic has an autostop function that shuts off the engine when it would normally be idling at a traffic light or if you pull over temporarily. As soon as you press on the gas the engine starts again very smoothly, and I have been very pleased with the autostop function.

Also, hybrids don't currently cost $5-8000 more than their gas engine counter parts, so I don't know how the prices would drop that much in the coming years...

azstinger11's picture
Posts
459
Member
1096 days
azstinger11 posted 1 year ago.

/delete poor American car build quality rant

-----------------------------------------------
Base 1 (Week 2, 16.5hrs)
Check out my blog!

tsilcyc's picture
Posts
872
Member
1238 days
tsilcyc posted 1 year ago.

While browsing a magazine, I saw the Nissan Rogue. I looked it up on Edmunds and it appeears to score well with the users. The editors still like the CRV better though. I went by the dealership and looked it at but I didn't drive it. Does anyone have one of these?

-------------------------------------------------------------------
Check out my Log: http://www.felog.net/users/teamsln/query_log.aspx
Check out my Blog: http://www.felog.net/feblog/

FlashRedGLS1.8T's picture
Posts
179
Member
933 days
FlashRedGLS1.8T posted 1 year ago.

tsilcyc wrote:
While browsing a magazine, I saw the Nissan Rogue. I looked it up on Edmunds and it appeears to score well with the users. The editors still like the CRV better though. I went by the dealership and looked it at but I didn't drive it. Does anyone have one of these?

I don't have one but I like it better than the CRV. More sporty. If you don't mind the CVT transmission, you should look at them seriously.

tsilcyc's picture
Posts
872
Member
1238 days
tsilcyc posted 1 year ago.

FlashRedGLS1.8T wrote:
I don't have one but I like it better than the CRV. More sporty. If you don't mind the CVT transmission, you should look at them seriously.

Yeah... i like the look as well. I don't know how well it will hold bikes though. The CRV looks bigger.

What is a CVT transmission?

-------------------------------------------------------------------
Check out my Log: http://www.felog.net/users/teamsln/query_log.aspx
Check out my Blog: http://www.felog.net/feblog/

Socket's picture
Posts
755
Member
911 days
Socket posted 1 year ago.

I had 3 "American" cars, all Ford, all serious POSes. My girlfriend had a Chevy that almost fell apart by the time the lease was up. My parents had Pontiacs that lasted forever and a half and my sister had a Buick that was very much a tank. Now I'm in a Toyota, Mom's in a Honda, Dad's in a Lexus, one sister is in a Hyundai, and the other rides a motorcycle.

Are US based automakers making crappy cars? Some are, some did. All I know is that my Fords all cost more in repairs (Tempo, Escort, Focus) than for the cars themselves and I have yet to have an issue with my Corolla that gets 10 MPG better milage without even needing to be a hybrid; it was also likely produced in one of Toyota's 13 North American plants.

As for the hybrid price drop: that'd happen anyway. Technology advances, demand increases, and economy of scale kicks in. Don't need inside information to figure that out. What I would like to know is why a couple guys in their garage or a pack of kids from west Philly can make a 90-100 MPG car using existing technology and the "big 3" can't.

< / rant >

tri-ac's picture
Posts
2766
Member
1445 days
tri-ac posted 1 year ago.

no one's even ranted yet on american car design...

stewarba's picture
Posts
491
Member
860 days
stewarba posted 1 year ago.

Socket wrote:
What I would like to know is why a couple guys in their garage or a pack of kids from west Philly can make a 90-100 MPG car using existing technology and the "big 3" can't.
< / rant >

And there is the Billion dollar question. Technologically look what society has acchieved in the past 50 years, but the biggest technilogical break throughs in automobiles has been with the stereo systems. Oh sure there have been computer chips added to the fuel injection systems and the whole nine yards but underneath it all you still have the same tired combustion engine. In the computer industry we call that a wrapper and its only used as a stop-gap until a more robust system can be developed.

I just hope and pray that the hybrid is a stop-gap and that the big three are pooring some IR&D dollars into a legitimate alternative in order to regain market share. I think it will be a race like we haven't seen since the space program ;-)

Hopefully big oil doesn't foil it!

Pain is the sensation of weakness leaving the body!

ChunkyB's picture
Posts
1037
Member
768 days
ChunkyB posted 1 year ago.

tri-ac wrote:
no one's even ranted yet on american car design...

How's this:

American cars are freaking butt-ugly (is that supposed to be hyphenated). American car companies need to stop living in the past when they used to be the kings of the mountain, and start making decent cars that run well and are nice looking. It's hilarious to watch those GM commercials that were running for a while that basically just said "Hey, look at all these sweet muscle cars we used to make. Remember all those great memories you use to have of Chevy's. Hey, there are even a bunch of popular songs that mention Chevrolet cars in the song. You should buy our cars, if not out of american pride and loyalty, then at least out of pity, because our whole company is going down the crapper."

I've heard that Ford has made some good strides in quality, but their cars are still so stinking ugly.

"The melting point of wax means nothing to me": Thrice

tritoride28's picture
Posts
80
Member
583 days
tritoride28 posted 1 year ago.

Tsilcyc,

You asked what a CVT transmission was and implicitly, how it works.

http://auto.howstuffworks.com/cvt.htm

In short, a CVT uses a pully system that controls the driven and driving "gears" that can change diameter. It is a system that does not change gears, but seemlessly changes ratios using cone type gears that expand and contract to give different sizes of "gears".

The Nissan Rogue has it as well as some models of the Saturn Vue.

Hope this helps.

Ronbo's picture
Posts
7
Member
598 days
Ronbo posted 1 year ago.

Check this out, two bike mounts inside the Honda Element.

http://automobiles.honda.com/element/accessory-detail.aspx?Accessory=ELE...

Do not own one, but am seriously looking at them.

tritoride28's picture
Posts
80
Member
583 days
tritoride28 posted 1 year ago.

I seriously considered an element, before I fiddled around in back and decided that I didnt want to block my windows by folding my seats up by them. Although the tailgate feature is pretty cool, you can only pack 600 pounds, including people into an element, and thats not going to work for camping+cycling+dogs.

Ryan's picture
Posts
60
Member
1598 days
Ryan posted 1 year ago.

This is simply not true, especially because you overlook the difference between different types of hybrids. The prius primarily uses an electric motor, with the gasoline engine assisting when more power is needed. I don't own the prius, but I would imagine that is where the figure of 20 mph keeps coming from (that it operates solely on the electric motor under 20 mph).

The civic hybrid on the other hand uses a gasoline engine primarily and the electric motor comes on when more power is needed (when accelerating or going up hills). Since you accelerate and go up hills on highways and back roads, you get a significant mpg boost even when you are not in the city. In addition to the regenerative braking, the civic has an autostop function that shuts off the engine when it would normally be idling at a traffic light or if you pull over temporarily. As soon as you press on the gas the engine starts again very smoothly, and I have been very pleased with the autostop function.

Also, hybrids don't currently cost $5-8000 more than their gas engine counter parts, so I don't know how the prices would drop that much in the coming years...

All Hybrids have a Electric and Gas motor. All run on electric until the power is needed. All run on electric when in idle. Trust me, I design them for one of the big three. The difference with all of them is weight. The Civic and Prius are small cars to begin with, therefore they require less power to get up to speed, hence better MPG. With a EscapeH, VueH, etc, these are larger vehicles with more weight, therefore using the Gas a little bit more. If your driving the freeway all the time, your not using the hybrid technology like you would be if you were stop in go in city traffic, rarely using power to get up to a faster speed.

Hybrids are expensive and that's whey they are having a tough time selling. The Government has a plan in the works to pay $5K of the cost of every new hybrid, essentially bringing the cost down. This is to replace the current tax break you get now when you own a hybrid. We estimate this to go into effect in 09 or 10.

Forza Nerazzurri

Jay's picture
Posts
49
Member
587 days
Jay posted 1 year ago.

LOL
i am a car guy so i will hold out as long as i can before buying a car that takes batteries.
and as a guy who runs and rides, i think they should make some noise, to hard to hear when i am out running or riding. there ar eplenty of hybrids here where i live. as wellas the smart cars.
there just dangereous.

Sportitude's picture
Posts
2
Member
561 days
Sportitude posted 1 year ago.

I have a GMC AWD Safari van. Its great in the winter and can hold a lot of cargo inside, and out. I get around 21mpg with it loaded light and 16-17mpg with 7 passangers and some light gear.

http://www.thesportitude.com/ "The right attitude for every sport"

tsilcyc's picture
Posts
872
Member
1238 days
tsilcyc posted 1 year ago.

To continue on with the car buying saga...

I went to drive the Rogue and the CRV. The dealerships are back to back so within 30 minutes, I had driven both and still managed to get off the lot without buying.

The Rogue:

- manly appearance
- drives nice
- ok driver visibility
- quiet drive
- so so power
- the engine is a little strange but fine
- square footage -- seems small but I could probably get two bikes in there

The CRV:

- emasculating appearance
- drives nice
- good visibility
- quiet drive
- ok power
- normal engine
- tons of square footage but the seats fold in a goofy way

Summary:

I like the exterior of the Rogue but I like the CRV better overall. If the Rogue would hold the bikes easily, I'd probably get it because the back seats in the CRV fold up but don't lock. And when I was driving it, one of them fell.

To be continued...

-------------------------------------------------------------------
Check out my Log: http://www.felog.net/users/teamsln/query_log.aspx
Check out my Blog: http://www.felog.net/feblog/

kylie's picture
Posts
5318
Member
1999 days
kylie posted 1 year ago.

For some reason I think there is a way to lock the seats into the fold position in the CRV -- a strap with a hook or something. I've never bothered as I've never once had one even move while folder flat against the front. Just make sure you fold it all the way up there.

Miles of Life --- Powered by MarkyV

tsilcyc's picture
Posts
872
Member
1238 days
tsilcyc posted 1 year ago.

I thought it was kind of odd that they didn't lock but I asked sales guy and he said they didn't. But now that I really think about it, he has to be wrong. It came down too easily when I accelerated.

-------------------------------------------------------------------
Check out my Log: http://www.felog.net/users/teamsln/query_log.aspx
Check out my Blog: http://www.felog.net/feblog/

kylie's picture
Posts
5318
Member
1999 days
kylie posted 1 year ago.

That's just weird... mine have never moved at all. I could take a look tomorrow, but I know there is a strapish thing in the back of them. Although I bet you were driving the 08... mine is an 04 so might just be different.

Miles of Life --- Powered by MarkyV

tritoride28's picture
Posts
80
Member
583 days
tritoride28 posted 1 year ago.

I thought that was weird with the CRV too. The seats didnt seem to fully fold down. I had the same reaction as tsilcyc when I test drove a CRV. It handled well, had sufficient power and lots of room in the driving position as well as cargo room. The one thing i didnt like was a lack of a center consol and the ride height. I felt like it was too tall for me.

One thing to consider may be the Rav4 if you havent researched it already. It has lots of cargo space, the rear seats come out completely and it has no spare tire in the rear cargo area, so you have a deeper region for stuff. The reason I didnt like it so much was because of the driving position and amount of room up front. I am a pretty big guy and like to stretch out a bit and the Rav4 did not give me that, as i felt constrained. But on the plus side the 4 cycliner gets great mileage for a small SUV and the V6 also does pretty well.

Jay's picture
Posts
49
Member
587 days
Jay posted 1 year ago.

the rear seats in my 4dr sidekick fold up as well behind the drivers seat. there is a little vinly strap witha hook that goes to a loop that holds the seat up. maybe something similar int eh crv.