car GPS
i have a garmin nuvi 200 (i believe), it is very basic but works great. it is small enough to travel with and it even has a bike mount for the reaaaaaally long rides (kidding, i dont want to break my toy while riding). i think it is in your price range (it was a gift so i am not 100% sure).
i also have the garmin nuvi 200. i think its a great product and it has gotten me to many races across the midwest. it is simple to set up: just mount it to your dash with the included adhesive or the suction cup for the windshield. the map is easy to read, updates very fast, & and the touch screen interface works well. i think i paid $250 at best buy.
I use a Magellan Maestro 4040.
That one may be a bit more than you want to spend, but look at Magellan. When I was shopping, I liked the Maestro interface more than any other brand and the Garmin equivalent to mine cost about $200 more for virtually the same thing. Magellan is also better than Garmin about letting you update maps and firmware for free (though it's not Mac compatible, last time I checked, which is a problem for me)
From a technical standpoint, one "shootout" I read indicated that Garmin was, in fact, the king of efficient routing algorithms, but the Magellan was close and most of the others were crap. I have used Garmin GPS units in rental cars and find that they actually take longer to recalculate the route if you make a wrong turn than my Magellan does, which I've heard is attributable to the Magellan trying to get you back onto the track you were on without calculating the whole thing, whereas the Garmin routine tries to recalculate the entire route before displaying it. The result is that the Garmin may actually be slightly more efficient (I have had experiences where I take a known shortcut with Magellan and it would rather have me backtrack than continue forward) but when you're in an unknown place and accidentally make a wrong turn, having a reasonable solution quickly is a great asset.
Other things I like about Magellan
-Great windshield mount. They do have a sit-on-the-dash adapter, but I personally don't like those and the windshield mount is extremely stable, unobtrusive, and easy to remove.
-Compact with no flip-out antennas or anything goofy like that. This is particularly nice when you want to use it out of the car for walking around or something. Mine, as a widescreen, is a bit big to carry around, but I have used it to navigate on foot.
Overall I love my GPS. I fire it up sometimes just to go 2 miles to the grocery store just because it's kind of fun. A lot of people talk about "aw, just learn to use maps, learn how to drive" and all this, but using a GPS really can change the way you drive. Last summer I moved from Annapolis, Maryland to Monterey, CA and did the road trip via Annapolis -> Louisville, KY -> Denver, CO -> Phoenix, AZ -> Los Angeles -> Monterey and didn't prepare a single map or anything ahead of time. Magellan never once let me down.
Fun experiment, too, is to sit in the window seat on a plane and fire it up mid-flight. It takes a while to pick up satellites, but you can pick them up and get an accurate fix on your position including speed.
-Grant-
thanks for all that info ... let me also ask ... i am getting this for a girlfriend so what about ease of use on the Magellan ? Is the Magellan harder to use than a Garmin ?
Chris
``It's not as if I'm going to sit around and be a fat slob,''
Lance Armstrong 2005
I, personally, find the Magellan extremely easy to use and intuitive. I'm a Computer Science student with a lot of experience in "Human Computer Interaction" so good interfaces are very important to me.
One really nice features is that it predicts things like street and city names as you're typing them by graying out letters on the keyboard that can't come next. That is, if you type "MA" and the only street names in the current city which start with MA are Maple, Mayberry, and Macon, only the P,Y,C keys will be active. This makes it really easy to type fast and you can be a bit sloppy, which is nice if you have to type while driving.
My fiancee was able to use it effectively the first time she tried.
If you go to Best Buy or somewhere like that, they'll have several on display that you can play with. That was the most important factor for me in choosing the one that I liked the best. I suspect different people will "click" with different units and perhaps the best way to tell is to try them all.
-Grant-
I just got a Tom Tom for Christmas....I haven't used it much yet but I like it so far!
GGehrke .. i went and tried some of the systems out today ... i really like the Magellan. the feature i like the most is as you explaied when you are typing a place it will grey out the letters that cannot be chosen which makes typing so easy. the unit would also pre drive the route whcih i thought was a cool feature as you could watch it.
i noticed there were some good menu options on the Magellan as where with the garmin it was very basic......i would have liked to see how the Garmin looked as it was driving a route but you can't as the unit is fixed in the store and does not have that feature.
Right now I am leaning toward that Magellan I thought its functionality just seemed better.
thanks for your help everyone.
Chris
``It's not as if I'm going to sit around and be a fat slob,''
Lance Armstrong 2005
I bought a Magellan in 2006 and used it from Ohio to South Carolina, and then for a week while down there. When we got back, I took it back to the store. It wasn't horrible, but we kept looking at the directions it gave, and then comparing it with how we would get there, and it never made sense. I did like how it grayed out all the letters that you didn't need to see when typing.
We have a Garmin now, and I like it. The charger is compatible with my Garmin Forerunner 305, both cell phones, and the bluetooth headset I have. There's an accessory so you can sit it on your dash with a beanbag type thing instead of sticking it to the window with a suction cup. Last thing I can think of that's different than the Magellan is it shows you the estimated time of arrival. Maybe Maggy (as my daughter called it) could be set to do that also, not sure.





can anyone suggest a car GPS ? i notice they have a very wide price range and i am not sure what to look for. i've been reading user reviews on new egg and i am willing to spend about 250-300. i dont need options like hooking the phone up and such. just a nice easy to use touch screen menu and updates easily. i notice the tom tom device have the maps on SD cards.
i'd like something that just sits on the dash.
Chris
``It's not as if I'm going to sit around and be a fat slob,''
Lance Armstrong 2005